Why Honor Heroes? Praise as a Social Signal

Jean-Louis Dessalles
2024-08-08
Abstract:Heroes are people who perform costly altruistic acts. Few people turn out to be heroes, but most people spontaneously honor heroes overtly by commenting, applauding, or enthusiastically celebrating their deeds. This behavior seems odd from an individual fitness optimization perspective. The best strategy should be to rely on others to invest time and effort in celebrations. To explain the universal propensity to pay tribute, we propose that public admiration is a way for admirers to signal that they are committed to the same values as the hero. We show that the emergence of heroic acts is an expected side-effect of this propensity.
Physics and Society,Populations and Evolution
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem this paper attempts to address is explaining why people spontaneously praise heroic behavior. From the perspective of evolutionary biology, heroic behavior (i.e., high-cost altruistic behavior) seems disadvantageous for the propagation of an individual's genes, as heroes often risk their lives or endure severe consequences to help others. However, there is a widespread phenomenon of high praise for heroic behavior in society. This paper proposes a hypothesis that such public praise for heroes is actually a social signaling mechanism, indicating that the praiser shares the same values as the hero. By constructing a simple social game model, the paper demonstrates that under certain conditions, this praising behavior can lead to the emergence of heroic behavior, and this behavior pattern can stabilize within a group. Additionally, the paper explores the variation in the number of heroes under different group sizes and social signaling cost conditions. In summary, this study aims to reveal the evolutionary logic behind heroic behavior and the social mechanisms that lead to its praise.