TUBERCULOSIS AS SEEN BY THE GENERAL PRACTITIONER *

R. Cameron
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.2.3527.243
1928-08-11
British Medical Journal
Abstract:CONCLUSIONS. A study of this series of cases for ces one to the coniclusioni that the opinion which many of the earlier observers had that artificial heliotherapy would prove an almost specific treatmiient for cases of surgical tuberculosis has lnot been justified. Witlhout placin-g too great weight on anyv of the figures, an(id without seeking to arrive at fin-al conclusions, I thinik it may be stated that in the series here detailed the results of cases treated by heliotherapy do not show any marked imnprovemen-t over the cases of a sim-lilar natture treated without lieliotherapy. There are figures which suggest that spinal disease and abdominal disease have been benefited bv the ultra-violet light treatmnent, but must we then conclude that the glandular disease in the neck and disease of the knee-joint are unaffected, while disease of the hip-joint is definitelv made worse by tlle heliotherapy? I prefer to draw the siml)le conclusion that on the whole the results obtainied by the use of artificial leliotherapy, when combinied with rouitine sanatorium treatment anld efficient local treatment, do not shlow any material improvemient over the' resullts obtained by treatinig cases by similar methods but witliouheliotherpap. I believe that the reason for the increased average stav in hospital is duie to the fact that the patieiits look so weil anid tanined that w^-e are inclined to give the local lesion, however resistanit to treatient, " another chanice." One is almost tempted to ask the question, What would the rlesults of the earlier cases hiave beeni if they, too, had enijoyed the more prolonged sanatorium treatnment? The coniclusioni reached is that artificial heliotherapy does not clhanige the fud(lamental principles of tr eatmenit of surgical tuberculosis. The efficient local measures taken to ensuro rest and the genieral sanatorium treatment are the main metlhods to be adopted; heliotherapy is a useful aid to treatment, as are many drugs. This last poilnt I would specially emnphasize, because it is frequently observed that patients ares moved in order that they mav go to the sun-room; sp1lints and other apparatus which are uisually religiously kept in place and uindistur-bed are then r-egarded as merely a nuisance an-d a hindrance to the transporting of the lpatient to the health-giving rays. I have to express my indebtedness to Mr. F. E. Jardine for his permission to use these figures.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?