Abstract:Topologically associating domains, or TADs, are functional units that organize chromosomes into 3D structures of interacting chromatin. TADs play an important role in regulating gene expression by constraining enhancer-promoter contacts and there is evidence that deletion of TAD boundaries leads to aberrant expression of neighboring genes. While the mechanisms of TAD formation have been well-studied, current knowledge on the patterns of TAD evolution across species is limited. Due to the integral role TADs play in gene regulation, their structure and organization is expected to be conserved during evolution. However, more recent research suggests that TAD structures diverge relatively rapidly. We use Hi-C chromosome conformation capture to measure evolutionary conservation of whole TADs and TAD boundary elements between D. melanogaster and D. triauraria, two early-branching species from the melanogaster species group which diverged ∼15 million years ago. We find that the majority of TADs have been reorganized since the common ancestor of D. melanogaster and D. triauraria, via a combination of chromosomal rearrangements and gain/loss of TAD boundaries. TAD reorganization between these two species is associated with a localized effect on gene expression, near the site of disruption. By separating TADs into subtypes based on their chromatin state, we find that different subtypes are evolving under different evolutionary forces. TADs enriched for broadly expressed, transcriptionally active genes are evolving rapidly, potentially due to positive selection, whereas TADs enriched for developmentally-regulated genes remain conserved, presumably due to their importance in restricting gene-regulatory element interactions. These results provide novel insight into the evolutionary dynamics of TADs and help to reconcile contradictory reports related to the evolutionary conservation of TADs and whether changes in TAD structure affect gene expression.

3D genome evolution and reorganization in the Drosophila melanogaster species group

TAD evolutionary and functional characterization reveals diversity in mammalian TAD boundary properties and function

Development and Evolution of Drosophila Chromatin Landscape in a 3D Genome Context

Evolutionary analysis of gene ages across TADs associates chromatin topology with whole genome duplications

Development and Evolution of Drosophila Chromatin Landscape in a 3D Genome Context.

Sub-kb Hi-C in D. Melanogaster Reveals Conserved Characteristics of TADs Between Insect and Mammalian Cells

Evolutionarily Conserved Principles Predict 3D Chromatin Organization.

Clustered CTCF binding is an evolutionary mechanism to maintain topologically associating domains

Deciphering the species-level structure of topologically associating domains

Three-dimensional folding dynamics of the Xenopus tropicalis genome

Evolutionary patterns and functional effects of 3D chromatin structures in butterflies with extensive genome rearrangements

Capturing the complexity of topologically associating domains through multi-feature optimization

A TAD Skeptic: Is 3D Genome Topology Conserved?

Evolutionary analysis of gene ages across TADs associates chromatin topology with whole-genome duplications

Pushing the TAD boundary: Decoding insulator codes of clustered CTCF sites in 3D genomes

Genome organization controls transcriptional dynamics during development

Reorganization of 3D Genome Structure May Contribute to Gene Regulatory Evolution in Primates

Structural Heterogeneity And Functional Diversity Of Topologically Associating Domains In Mammalian Genomes

Long-range interactions between topologically associating domains shape the four-dimensional genome during differentiation

Systematic Chromatin Architecture Analysis in Xenopus tropicalis Reveals Conserved Three-Dimensional Folding Principles of Vertebrate Genomes

A complex CTCF binding code defines TAD boundary structure and function