Newman's Grammar of Assent and the Diagnostic Process

W. Beautyman
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1353/PBM.1982.0046
2015-01-07
Perspectives in Biology and Medicine
Abstract:Newman's Idea of a University [1] is frequently quoted in connection with medical education, but the relevance of his Grammar of Assent to diagnosis has had scant recognition [2-4]. Yet the making of a diagnosis is essentially a matter of giving assent to a proposition, for example, Mrs. Jones has subacute bacterial endocarditis; and in Newman's work, we have the most comprehensive and elegant treatment of the subject in the English language. Indeed, it adumbrates many of the more recent observations that have been made on the nature of science and diagnosis, and it brings together many aspects of human thought relevant to such matters that are elsewhere treated in isolation, if at all.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?