Abstract:Abstract The finding of Yang et al. (2021; hereafter, YSR21) casts fundamental doubts on all the previous studies on the temporal changes of the inner core (IC) surface that are based on absolute arrival times, including Wen (2006; hereafter, WEN06) and its follow-up studies. The reports of small time shifts of the IC-reflected phase (PKiKP) likely misinterpreted station-related issues (clock errors and instrument changes) as evidence for rapid localized deformation at the IC surface. The comment by Zhang and Wen (2024; hereafter, ZW24) aims at defending the results and conclusions of WEN06 by questioning a tiny portion of the results (2 out of over 400 doublets and 3 out of over 400 problematic stations) in YSR21. In response, we acknowledge an accidental error in table S1 of YSR21, which is corrected in an erratum (Yang et al., 2023), although this does not affect the results or interpretations of YSR21. However, we strongly disagree with the criticisms in ZW24 due to many problems therein, especially the issue of irreproducibility due to its inconsistent procedures with YSR21. While the problems are related to the use of absolute arrivals in the previous studies by Wen’s group, key problems in this new comment are related to questionable data selection and inconsistent processing. We further caution the metadata updates, particularly when involving small temporal change signals. We focus on the main points in ZW24 and demonstrate that its arguments are problematic in many aspects and do not diminish the credibility of YSR21 or other related works by Yang and Song in support of the IC differential rotation.

Response to Comment on "Revised paleoaltimetry data show low Tibetan Plateau elevation during the Eocene"

Corrigendum: Exploiting Thermochronology to Quantify Exhumation Histories and Patterns of Uplift Along the Margins of Tibet (Front. Earth Sci, (2021), 9, (688374), 10.3389/feart.2021.688374)

Reply to comment by Zhao et al. on “Hydrothermal events in the Linzizong Group: Implications for Paleogene exhumation and paleoaltimetry of the southern Tibetan Plateau”

Revised paleoaltimetry data show low Tibetan Plateau elevation during the Eocene

Reply to Comment by Zhao Et Al. on “paleomagnetism of the Late Cretaceous Red Beds from the Far Western Lhasa Terrane: Inclination Discrepancy and Tectonic Implications”

Response to Comment on "An update of Wallace's zoogeographic regions of the world".

Comment On: "hydrothermal Events in the Linzizong Group: Implications for Paleogene Exhumation and Paleoaltimetry of the Southern Tibetan Plateau" by Huang Et Al. (2022)

Opportunities and Challenges for Paleoaltimetry in "small" Orogens: Insights from the European Alps

Reply to the Comment on “discovery of Radiolaria from Upper Cretaceous Oceanic Red Beds in Daba, Kangmar and Its Paleogeographic Implication” by Li Et Al., 2011 [palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 312 (2011) 127–137]

Interactive comment on “ Rock glaciers in the Daxue Shan , southeastern Tibetan Plateau : an inventory , their distribution , and their environmental controls ” by Zeze Ran

Atallah et al. reply

Reply to Comment by Rashid Et Al. on “asynchronous Variation in the East Asian Winter Monsoon During the Holocene”

Response to Comment on "A global environmental crisis 42,000 years ago"

Reply to Comment on “Multi-fractal characteristics of reconstructed landform and its relationship with soil erosion at a large opencast coal-mine in the loess area of China” by Shi et al. (2021)

Reply to “comment on ‘an Evaluation of the Timing Accuracy of Global and Regional Seismic Stations and Networks’ by Yang Et Al. (2021)” by Xin Zhang and Lianxing Wen

Correction: Corrigendum: Possible recent warming hiatus on the northwestern Tibetan Plateau derived from ice core records

Author Correction: A Lake Data Set for the Tibetan Plateau from the 1960s, 2005, and 2014

Interactive comment on “ Uncertainty of the CO 2 threshold for melting a hard Snowball Earth ” by

Cambrian to Triassic geodynamic evolution of central Qiangtang, Tibet: Reply