Interactive comment on “ Rock glaciers in the Daxue Shan , southeastern Tibetan Plateau : an inventory , their distribution , and their environmental controls ” by Zeze Ran

Daxue Shan,Geng-nian Liu
2018-01-01
Abstract:General Comments This paper provides the first inventory of rock glaciers in the Daxue Shan, including an analysis of the topographic controls on them, so fits the general scope of the The Cryosphere. However, there are a few major issues that will need to be addressed before the paper can be published: 1. The outlines provided in the supplementary material often appear to provide outlines of basins which may contain rock glaciers, but they don’t do a good job of outlining the actual rock glaciers themselves. Many of the outlines also appear to define talus deposits or debris-covered C1
What problem does this paper attempt to address?