Abstract:Background: GP referrals to secondary care are an important factor in the cost of running the NHS. The known variation in referral rates between doctors has the potential to cause tension within primary care which will be exacerbated by the latest reorganization of primary care and the trend towards capitation-based budgets. The importance of postgraduate learning for GPs has been recognized; continuing professional development is moving towards self-directed practice-based learning programmes. Educational interventions have been shown to alter doctors' prescribing behaviour. This, together with the pressure on accounting for referral activity, makes the prospect of improving, and possibly reducing, referral activity through educational interventions very attractive. Objectives: This study complemented a randomized controlled trial (RCT) which investigated whether an intervention of the type which had reduced prescribing costs would have a similar effect on referral activity. Methods: The context of the study, description of the characteristics of the practice and the issues seen as important by the doctors and practice manager were identified through preliminary semi-structured interviews. The practice then held a series of educational in-practice meetings to discuss referrals and issues arising from referrals. The audio- and videotaped transcripts were interpreted using content and group dynamic analysis. Participants commented upon our preliminary findings. In addition, we used dimensional analysis to induce a preliminary theory describing the effect of the intervention on this general practice which enabled us to review the findings of the parallel RCT. The educational value of the meetings and the learning needs of the participants were also assessed. Results: Our complementary study showed no alteration of practice referral rates following the educational intervention. The qualitative study, unencumbered by the assumptions inherent in the development of the hypothesis tested in the RCT, highlighted the complexity of decision making in general practice and the likely impact of historical background and a variety of internal and external pressures on this self-directive educational intervention. The practice members described the individual and group learning needs identified as a result of the meetings. Conclusion: The findings of this study raise important questions for developing practice-based learning. The outcomes of self-directive interventions in practices will be influenced by internal and external events both past and present. Such outcomes may be qualitative and difficult to measure. They are likely to differ from outcomes seen when interventions are applied to groups of doctors who are not all members of the same practice.

Sending emails to reduce medical costs? The effect of feedback on general practitioners' claiming of fees

Feedback of Laboratory Usage and Cost Data to Clinicians: Does It Alter Requesting Behaviour?

Modifying the Request Behaviour of Clinicians.

How do patients and general practitioners in Denmark perceive the communicative advantages and disadvantages of access via email consultations? A media-theoretical qualitative study

Time is money: general practitioners' reflections on the fee-for-service system

Evaluating a novel online behavioural intervention to encourage cost-conscious strategies among US adults with chronic conditions who are enrolled in a high-deductible health plan: a proof-of-concept pilot study

Randomised trial of general practitioner online education for prescribing and test ordering

How to save costs by reducing unnecessary testing: lean thinking in clinical practice

Hospital doctors' attitudes to brief educational messages that aim to modify diagnostic test requests: a qualitative study

Feedback and Training to Improve Use of an Electronic Prescribing System: A Randomised Controlled Trial.

Mapping out the arguments for and against patient non-attendance fees in healthcare: an analysis of public consultation documents

Behavioral Nudges to Improve Audit and Feedback Report Opening Among Antibiotic Prescribers: A Randomized Controlled Trial

Implementation of an educational intervention to improve medical student cost awareness: a prospective cohort study

What Interventions Work to Reduce Cost Barriers to Primary Healthcare in High-Income Countries? A Systematic Review

Referrals and relationships: in-practice referrals meetings in a general practice

WELCOME-GP: A randomised controlled trial of the effectiveness of a targeted postal cancer awareness intervention for increasing attendance at general practice

CHIME-GP trial of online education for prescribing, pathology and imaging ordering in general practice - how did it bring about behaviour change?

Clinical audit as a tool to optimize contracted private healthcare provision: Testing the waters in resource-deprived Greece

Reducing low‐value imaging—A qualitative evaluation of a pilot intervention in Norway

Patient-initiated Electronic Messages and Quality of Care for Patients With Diabetes and Hypertension in a Large Fee-for-Service Medical Group: Results From a Natural Experiment

What effect do point of care fees have on childhood consultations in general practice?