Abstract:A detailed quantitative analysis was performed on data presented in the literature that focused on the sequential extraction of cadmium (Cd), chromium (Cr), copper (Cu), nickel (Ni), lead (Pb) and zinc (Zn) from the certified reference material BCR-701 (lake sediment) using the three-step harmonized BCR(®) procedure. The accuracy of data reported in the literature, including precision and different measures of trueness, was assessed relative to the certified values for BCR-701. Forty data sets were accepted following extreme outlier removal, and statistically summarized with measures of central tendency, dispersion, and distribution form. In general, literature data were similar in their measurement precision to the expert laboratories used to certify the trace element contents in BCR-701. The overall median precision for literature reported data was 10% (range 6-19%), compared to certifying laboratories of 9% (range 4-33%). One measure of literature data trueness was assessed via a confirmatory approach using a robust bootstrap method. Only 22% of the comparisons indicated significantly different (all were lower) concentrations reported in the literature compared to certified values. The question of whether the differences are practically significant for environmental studies is raised. Bias was computed as a measure of trueness, and literature data were more frequently negatively biased, indicating lower concentrations reported in the literature for the six trace elements for the three-step sequential procedure compared to the certified values. However, 95% confidence intervals about the average bias for the 18 comparisons indicated only four instances when a mean bias of 0 (i.e., measured=certified) was not incorporated-suggesting statistical difference. Finally, Z-scores incorporating a Horwitz-type function were used to assess the general trueness of laboratory data. Of the 468 laboratory Z-score values computed, 92% were considered to be satisfactory, 5% were questionable, and 3% were unsatisfactory. A detailed examination of the methodology sections of the various studies showed that despite claiming adherence to the harmonized BCR sequential extraction protocol, significant deviations were commonly observed; particularly in moisture correction, sample mass, centrifugation specifics, shaking specifics, and incorporation of filtration. It is likely that failure to strictly adhere to the protocol adversely impacted accuracy, by increasing the degree of imprecision and resulting in more discrepant trueness values.

An alternative sequential extraction scheme for the determination of trace elements in ferrihydrite rich sediments

A New Sequential Extraction Procedure for the Speciation of Particulate Trace Elements in River Sediments

Sequential extraction procedure for the speciation of particulate trace metals

Evaluation of a sequential extraction procedure for the speciation of heavy metals in sediments

Comparison of three sequential extraction protocols for the fractionation of potentially toxic metals in coastal sediments

New methodological approach for deep penetrating geochemistry and environmental studies part 1: on-site soil extraction of trace and rare earth elements

Fractionation of trace elements in agricultural soils using ultrasound assisted sequential extraction prior to inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometric determination

Optimization and assessment of a sequential extraction procedure for calcium carbonate rocks

Assessment of the Tessier and BCR sequential extraction procedures for elemental partitioning of Ca, Fe, Mn, Al, and Ti and their application to surface sediments from Chinese continental shelf

Conventional, microwave, and ultrasound sequential extractions for the fractionation of metals in sediments within the Petrochemical Industry, Serbia

Determination of molybdenum in extracts of soil and sewage sludge CRMs after fractionation by means of BCR modified sequential extraction procedure

The depositional redox conditions of Fe‐speciation reference materials (BHW and WHIT) using redox‐sensitive trace metal enrichment

Sequential chemical extraction and mineralogical bonding of metals from Styrian soils

Basis for a new process for producing REE oxides from Dicranopteris linearis

Selectivty Assessments of a Sequential Extraction Procedure for Potential Trace Metals’ Mobility and Bioavailability in Phosphate Rocks from Jordan Phosphate Mines

BCR®-701: a review of 10-years of sequential extraction analyses

Optimization of a sequential extraction procedure for trace elements in Arctic PM10

The removal of heavy metals from contaminated soil by a combination of sulfidisation and flotation

Determination of Aluminum Fractionation in Soil Extracts by Using Eriochrome Cyanine R Modified Anion-Exchange Resin As Solid Phase Extraction Cartridge Coupled with Icp-Aes

Isolation and microbial reduction of Fe(III) phyllosilicates from subsurface sediments

Assessing metal extraction from metalliferous waste: A study using deep eutectic solvents and chelating agents vs. ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid