Abstract:Purpose This study aims to modify the human factors analysis and classification system (HFACS) to make it suitable for collapse accident analysis in construction. Based upon the modified HFACS, distribution patterns of causal factors across multiple levels were discerned among causal factors of various stakeholders at construction sites. It explored the correlations between two causal factors from different levels and further determined causation paths from two perspectives of level and stakeholder. Design/methodology/approach The main research framework consisted of data collection, coding and analysis. Collapse accident reports were collected with adequate causation information. The modified HFACS was utilized for coding causal factors across all five levels in each case. A hybrid approach with two perspectives of level and stakeholder was proposed for frequency analysis, correlation analysis and path identification between causal factors. Findings Eight causal factors from external organizations at the fifth level were added to the original HFACS. Level-based correlation analyses and path identification provided safety managers with a holistic view of inter-connected causal factors across five levels. Stakeholder-based correlation analyses between causal factors from the fifth level and its non-adjacent levels were implemented based on client, government and third parties. These identified paths were useful for different stakeholders to develop specific safety plans for avoiding construction collapse accidents. Originality/value This paper fulfils an identified need to modify and utilize the HFACS model for correlation analysis and path identification of causal factors resulting in collapse accidents, which can provide opportunities for tailoring preventive and protective measures at construction sites.

Applicability of accident analysis methods to Chinese construction accidents

Identification of critical causes of construction accidents in China using a hybrid HFACS-CN model

Systemic Approaches to Incident Analysis in Coal Mines: Comparison of the STAMP, FRAM and “2–4” Models

STAMP-based Analysis on the Railway Accident and Accident Spreading: Taking the China–Jiaoji Railway Accident for Example

Research on STAMP Model Based Architectural Construction Accidents-- Citing the Event of "913" in East Lake Scenic Area, Wuhan

Construction Safety Accident-Causing Mechanism and Statistical Analysis Based on Case Data

Systems-Based Analysis of China-Tianjin Port Fire and Explosion: A Comparison of HFACS, AcciMap, and STAMP

Accident Causing Theory in Construction Safety Management

A System Thinking Analysis Approach for Construction Workplace Safety in China: an Example of a Simulation Model at a Site

A New Accident Causation Theory Based on Systems Thinking and Its Systemic Accident Analysis Method of Work Systems

Risk analysis of construction accidents with a weighted network model considering accident level

Modified accident causation model for highway construction accidents (ACM-HC)

Statistical Analysis and Risk control of Civil Engineering Safety Management Accidents

Study on the identification and control of operational safety accidents in construction

A Complex Network Approach to Modeling the Causations of Major Construction Safety Accidents

Analysis of the Characteristics of Fatal Accidents in the Construction Industry in China Based on Statistical Data

Accident Causation Models Developed in China Between 1978 and 2018: Review and Comparison

Analysis Of Construction Workers Safety Competencies Model

Analysis and Identification of Building Construction Accident Risk in China basing Exclusively Database

Cause Analysis of the Dangerous Factors in Construction Accidents and Their Countermeasures

Modification of HFACS model for path identification of causal factors of collapse accidents in the construction industry