A multiscale approach to balance trade-offs among dam infrastructure, river restoration, and cost

Samuel G Roy,Emi Uchida,Simone P de Souza,Ben Blachly,Emma Fox,Kevin Gardner,Arthur J Gold,Jessica Jansujwicz,Sharon Klein,Bridie McGreavy,Weiwei Mo,Sean M C Smith,Emily Vogler,Karen Wilson,Joseph Zydlewski,David Hart

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1807437115

2018-11-20

Abstract:Aging infrastructure and growing interests in river restoration have led to a substantial rise in dam removals in the United States. However, the decision to remove a dam involves many complex trade-offs. The benefits of dam removal for hazard reduction and ecological restoration are potentially offset by the loss of hydroelectricity production, water supply, and other important services. We use a multiobjective approach to examine a wide array of trade-offs and synergies involved with strategic dam removal at three spatial scales in New England. We find that increasing the scale of decision-making improves the efficiency of trade-offs among ecosystem services, river safety, and economic costs resulting from dam removal, but this may lead to heterogeneous and less equitable local-scale outcomes. Our model may help facilitate multilateral funding, policy, and stakeholder agreements by analyzing the trade-offs of coordinated dam decisions, including net benefit alternatives to dam removal, at scales that satisfy these agreements.