A Simulation–Optimization System to Assess Dam Construction with a Focus on Environmental Degradation at Downstream

Mahdi Sedighkia,Asghar Abdoli

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11269-024-03781-4

IF: 4.426

2024-02-24

Water Resources Management

Abstract:The present study proposes and evaluates an integrated framework to assess dam construction and removal, encompassing the simulation of downstream river habitats and reservoir operation in three distinct statuses: conventional reservoir operation optimization, optimal release considering environmental aspects within the optimization model, and natural flow conditions. Fuzzy physical habitat simulation was employed to assess physical habitats, while an ANFIS-based model was utilized to simulate thermal tension and dissolved oxygen tension at downstream habitats. Particle swarm optimization was applied in the optimization models. To evaluate the effectiveness of the proposed framework, results from the optimization system as well as habitat suitability models in the natural flow and current condition were compared using various measurement indices, including the reliability index, vulnerability index, the Nash–Sutcliffe model efficiency coefficient (NSE), and root mean square error (RMSE). The case study results suggest that the reliability of water supply may be diminished under optimal release for environmental and demand considerations. Additionally, optimal release for the environment may not adequately protect downstream aquatic habitats. Therefore, in cases where the preservation of downstream habitats is a priority, dam removal may be a logical solution. Moreover, it is essential to acknowledge that the main limitation of the proposed method is its high computational complexity.

water resources,engineering, civil

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to evaluate the impact of dam construction and removal on downstream environmental degradation, especially how to quantify and mitigate these impacts through simulation and optimization systems. Specifically, the research aims to:

1. **Propose and evaluate an integrated framework**: This framework is used to evaluate dam construction and removal, covering the simulation of downstream river habitats and the optimization of reservoir operations.
2. **Consider three different states**:
- Optimization of conventional reservoir operations
- Optimal release considering environmental factors in the optimization model
- Natural flow conditions

### Main problems and objectives

- **Evaluate the impact of dam construction and removal on the downstream environment**: Through simulation and optimization systems, study the impact of dam construction and removal on downstream river ecosystems, especially the changes in hydrological parameters and water quality.
- **Optimize reservoir operations**: While meeting water demand, minimize the negative impact on the downstream ecological environment as much as possible.
- **Explore the possibility of dam removal**: When protecting downstream habitats becomes a priority, evaluate whether dam removal is a reasonable solution.

### Research methods

To achieve the above - mentioned goals, the research adopts the following methods:

1. **Physical habitat simulation**: Use one - dimensional fuzzy physical habitat simulation (Fuzzy Physical Habitat Simulation) to evaluate physical habitats.
2. **Temperature and dissolved oxygen tension simulation**: Simulate thermal tension and dissolved oxygen tension based on the adaptive neuro - fuzzy inference system (ANFIS).
3. **Particle swarm optimization (PSO)**: Applied in the optimization model to minimize environmental degradation and reservoir losses.
4. **Evaluation indicators**: Use indicators such as reliability index, vulnerability index, Nash - Sutcliffe model efficiency coefficient (NSE) and root - mean - square error (RMSE) to evaluate model performance.

### Conclusions

The research shows that under the optimal release strategy considering environmental factors, although environmental degradation can be partially alleviated, it may not be sufficient to fully protect downstream aquatic habitats. Therefore, when it is necessary to give priority to protecting downstream habitats, dam removal may be a reasonable solution. In addition, the research emphasizes the crucial role of optimized operations in minimizing negative impacts and proposes opportunities to improve the simulation - optimization method.

Through this comprehensive framework, the research provides a flexible and adaptable method for evaluating dam removal projects, which helps to more comprehensively understand the impact of dam construction and removal on the environment.

### Formula summary

1. **Nash - Sutcliffe model efficiency coefficient (NSE)**:
\[
NSE = 1-\frac{\sum_{t = 1}^{T}(m_t - o_t)^2}{\sum_{t = 1}^{T}(o_t-\bar{o})^2}
\]
where \(m_t\) is the simulated or predicted value, \(o_t\) is the observed value, \(\bar{o}\) is the average of the observed values, and \(T\) is the number of samples.

2. **Optimization objective function (Scenario 1)**:
\[
OF=\sum_{t = 1}^{T}\left(\frac{D_t - R_t}{D_t}\right)^2
\]
where \(D_t\) is the maximum water demand and \(R_t\) is the release amount.

3. **Optimization objective function (Scenario 2)**:
\[
\text{Minimize }OF=\sum_{t = 1}^{T}\left(\frac{D_t - R_t}{D_t}\right)^2+\left(\frac{PHN_t - PHM_t}{PHN_t}\right)^2+\left(\frac{THN_t - THM_t}{THN_t}\right)^2+\left(\frac{DHN_t - DHM_t}{DHN_t}\right)^2+P1_t+P2_t+P3_t
\]
where \(PHN_t\)