Abstract:We give two social aggregation theorems under conditions of risk, one for constant population cases, the other an extension to variable populations. Intra and interpersonal welfare comparisons are encoded in a single 'individual preorder'. The theorems give axioms that uniquely determine a social preorder in terms of this individual preorder. The social preorders described by these theorems have features that may be considered characteristic of Harsanyi-style utilitarianism, such as indifference to ex ante and ex post equality. However, the theorems are also consistent with the rejection of all of the expected utility axioms, completeness, continuity, and independence, at both the individual and social levels. In that sense, expected utility is inessential to Harsanyi-style utilitarianism. In fact, the variable population theorem imposes only a mild constraint on the individual preorder, while the constant population theorem imposes no constraint at all. We then derive further results under the assumption of our basic axioms. First, the individual preorder satisfies the main expected utility axiom of strong independence if and only if the social preorder has a vector-valued expected total utility representation, covering Harsanyi's utilitarian theorem as a special case. Second, stronger utilitarian-friendly assumptions, like Pareto or strong separability, are essentially equivalent to strong independence. Third, if the individual preorder satisfies a 'local expected utility' condition popular in non-expected utility theory, then the social preorder has a 'local expected total utility' representation. Fourth, a wide range of non-expected utility theories nevertheless lead to social preorders of outcomes that have been seen as canonically egalitarian, such as rank-dependent social preorders. Although our aggregation theorems are stated under conditions of risk, they are valid in more general frameworks for representing uncertainty or ambiguity.

Multiperson utility

You Can't Always Get What You Want : Games of Ordered Preference

Finite multi-utility representable preferences and Pareto orderings

Utilitarianism with and without expected utility

Settling the Score: Portioning with Cardinal Preferences

Optimal Budget Aggregation with Star-Shaped Preferences

Local Aggregation in Preference Games

Multi Resource Allocation with Partial Preferences.

Mixture independence foundations for expected utility

Impartiality and relative utilitarianism

Desirability and social rankings

Mechanisms and axiomatics for division problems with single-dipped preferences

Expected utility theory with probability grids and preference formation

Graphical Models for Preference and Utility

From Incomplete Preferences to Ranking via Optimization

Combining Savage and Laplace: a new approach to ambiguity

Two principles for two-person social choice

Uniform Welfare Guarantees Under Identical Subadditive Valuations

A Fractional Hypercube Decomposition Theorem for Multiattribute Utility Functions

Public Projects with Preferences and Predictions

Seat Arrangement Problems under B-utility and W-utility