Abstract:Background: Harmonization methods reduce variability between different make and models of positron emission tomography (PET) scanners. The study aims to explore harmonization strategies that lead to comparable and robust quantitative metrics in a multicenter setting. Methods: NEMA IEC Phantom data acquisition was performed for low and high spheres-to-background ratios (SBR4:1 and 10:1) on six PET/CT (computed tomography) scanners. Different reconstruction sets, including the number of sub-iterations, number of subsets, and full width at half maximum (FWHM) for each scanner, were evaluated towards optimized and harmonized reconstruction settings. Recovery coefficients (RCs) of four quantitative metrics, including standardized uptake value (SUV)max, SUVISO-50 (SUVmean in 50% isocontour), SUVpeak, and mean uptake of 10 highest concentration voxels were evaluated as RCmax, RCISO-50, RCpeak, and RC10V, representing percent difference relative to the static ground truth case as functions of sphere sizes. A set of image reconstruction parameters was proposed for harmonized reconstruction to minimize variability between scanners. The root mean square error (RMSE), curvature, and reproducibility were examined. The proposed reconstruction protocols for harmonization and standard clinical reconstruction settings were compared to each other across all scanners. Results: A significant difference (P value <0.0001) was observed in the aforementioned quantitative metrics between SBR10 and SBR4. Reconstruction parameter sets with the smallest RMSE and RC values within 10% bias were identified as the best candidate for harmonization. The coefficient of variation of the mean value of RCs (CVMRC) shows a remarkable reduction of about 28%, 26%, 32%, and 19% in harmonized reconstruction settings for MRCmax, MRCISO-50, MRCpeak, and MRC10V, respectively. CVMRC for MRC10V in the harmonized reconstruction setting was 5.9% in SBR4, while the smallest value in SBR10 belongs to MRCpeak, with a value of 5.8%. The reproducibility of RC is improved by deriving the value from ten hottest voxels and is equally reproducible with RCpeak. Compared to RCmax and RCISO-50, the variability is reduced by 18% and 22% if ten voxels are pooled. Conclusions: Harmonizing PET/CT systems with and without point spread function/time of flight (PSF/TOF) using various vendor-developed image reconstruction algorithms improves the quantification reproducibility. RC10V, likewise RCpeak, is superior to the rest of the quantitative indices in terms of accuracy and reproducibility and helpful in quantifying lesion volume below 1 mL.

CT-guided spatial normalization of nuclear hybrid imaging adapted to enlarged ventricles: impact on striatal uptake quantification

Spatial normalization and quantification approaches of PET imaging for neurological disorders

Improving 18F-FDG PET Quantification Through a Spatial Normalization Method

Quantitative Intensity Harmonization of Dopamine Transporter SPECT Images Using Gamma Mixture Models

Voxel-wise regression without intensity normalization provides better sensitivity when identifying injury regions after stroke in FDG-PET images

Improved Quantification of MicroPET/CT Imaging Using CT-derived Scaling Factors

Evaluation of imaging protocol for ECT based on CS image reconstruction algorithm

Accurate Automated Quantification of Dopamine Transporter PET Without MRI Using Deep Learning-based Spatial Normalization

Accurate Whole-Brain Image Enhancement for Low-Dose Integrated PET/MR Imaging Through Spatial Brain Transformation

Automated stereotactic standardization of brain SPECT receptor data using single-photon transmission images

Convolutional neural network based attenuation correction for 123 I-FP-CIT SPECT with focused striatum imaging

Improved amyloid burden quantification with nonspecific estimates using deep learning

The influence of different signal-to-background ratios on spatial resolution and F18-FDG-PET quantification using point spread function and time-of-flight reconstruction

Quantitative Cerebral Blood Volume Image Synthesis from Standard MRI Using Image-to-Image Translation for Brain Tumors

Self-normalization for a 1 mm3resolution clinical PET system using deep learning

Quantitative Accuracy Assessment of the NeuroEXPLORER for Diverse Imaging Applications: Moving Beyond Standard Evaluations

Multicenter quantitative 18F-fluorodeoxyglucose positron emission tomography performance harmonization: use of hottest voxels towards more robust quantification

Partial volume correction of PET image data using geometric transfer matrices based on uniform B-splines

A support vector machine-based approach to guide the selection of a pseudo-reference region for brain PET quantification

Assessing CT-based Volumetric Analysis via Transfer Learning with MRI and Manual Labels for Idiopathic Normal Pressure Hydrocephalus

Single-Subject Deep-Learning Image Reconstruction with a Neural Optimization Transfer Algorithm for PET-enabled Dual-Energy CT Imaging