Abstract:Virtual nature is an innovative approach for promoting mental health. The purpose of this study was to compare the effects on mental health outcomes between two immersion levels of virtual reality natural experiences. The study design was a cluster trial. Healthy adults were allocated to two experimental groups. Identical pre-recorded 360° videos of natural scenes and sounds were played on the two virtual reality devices, one with a higher immersive level via a head-mounted display and the other one with a lower immersive level via a smartphone. The intervention was conducted for 30 min per session, once a week for 12 weeks. Data were collected by self-reported questionnaires at the baseline and post-intervention. In total, 54 participants completed the interventions. A significantly greater effect was revealed on improving happiness, self-rated health, and physical, mental, social, and environmental quality of life, and ameliorating distress, depression, and somatization in participants who experienced the higher immersive level compared to participants who experienced the lower immersive level. Virtual reality natural experiences with high immersion are recommended to promote mental health.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper discusses the impact of virtual reality (VR) natural experiences on mental health, specifically comparing the effects under different immersion levels (high immersion and low immersion). The study uses a cluster randomized trial design, dividing healthy adults into two groups, playing the same 360-degree natural scene videos through two types of VR devices, head-mounted displays (HMD) and smartphones. Participants received a 30-minute intervention once a week for 12 weeks. The study found that participants who experienced high-immersion level VR natural environments showed significant improvements in happiness, self-rated health, physical, mental, social, and environmental quality of life, while also reducing stress, depression, and psychosomatic symptoms, compared to the low-immersion level VR group. The paper emphasizes the importance of high immersion in enhancing user presence and improving mental health effects. The paper also reviews previous research, indicating that although VR natural experiences have shown benefits for mental health, previous studies have often used lower immersion levels and mostly observed short-term interventions. This study aims to fill the research gap regarding the differences in the impact of different VR immersion levels on mental health through long-term VR stimulation. The research methods involved recruiting participants from bank employees in two different offices to experience VR natural environments using HMD and smartphones. The results showed significant improvements in happiness, self-rated health, and more for the HMD group, while the smartphone group showed a slight decline. Furthermore, GEE analysis demonstrated improvements in multiple mental health indicators for the HMD group, while the smartphone group showed varying degrees of decline. In conclusion, this paper aims to address how different immersion levels of VR technology can promote mental health, and the results show that high-immersion level VR natural experiences have a greater positive impact on mental health.

Virtual reality natural experiences for mental health: comparing the effects between different immersion levels