Questionable prospective effect of grip strength on cognitive function: A simulated reanalysis and comment on Cui et al. (2024)

Kimmo Sorjonen,Bo Melin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.31234/osf.io/kpavm

IF: 4.163

2024-10-23

Archives of Gerontology and Geriatrics

Abstract:Based on findings from analyses with cross-lagged panel models, Cui et al. (2024) concluded that muscle strength, measured as grip strength, can protect against cognitive decline among the elderly. Here, we simulated data to resemble the data used by Cui et al. We used triangulation and fitted complementary models to the simulated data and found contradicting increasing, decreasing, and null effects of initial grip strength on subsequent change in cognitive function. These divergent findings suggest that it is premature to assume a protective effect of muscle strength on cognitive decline and the conclusion by Cui et al. in this regard can be challenged. It is important for researchers to be aware that correlations, including adjusted cross-lagged effects, do not prove causality in order not to overinterpret findings, something that appears to have happened to Cui et al. We recommend researchers to triangulate by fitting complementary models to their data in order to evaluate if observed effects may be due to true causal effect or if they appear to be spurious.

geriatrics & gerontology,gerontology