Abstract:Objective To compare the clinical outcomes of percutaneous cannulated lag screws versus posterior buttress plate in the fixation for posterior malleolar fractures.Methods We reviewed the 167 patients who had been treated between January 2010 and December 2014 for ankle fracture involving larger than 25％ of the articular surface of the posterior malleolus.They received posterior malleolus fixation with percutaneous cannulated lag screws or with a buttress plate.In the cannulated screw group (84 patients),there were 47 males and 37 females,aged from 23 to 72 years (average,49.7 ±9.1 years),and 39 cases of type B and 45 ones of type C according to the Dennis-Webber classification.In the buttress plate group (83 patients),there were 38 males and 45 females,aged from 31 to 69 years (average,52.3 ± 8.3 years),and 45 cases of type B and 38 ones of type C according to the Dennis-Webber classification.At 6 and 12 months postoperation and the final follow-up,the ankle motion was evaluated using American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society (AOFAS) score and range of motion (ROM).Results The average operation time for the cannulated screw group was significantly shorter than for the buttress plate group (Z =-9.145,P ＜ 0.001).No fracture nonunion,reduction loss or incision infection happened in either group.In the cannulated screw group,we detected malunion with a step-off beyond 2 mm in 5 patients,and penetration of one cannulated lag screw into the tibiofibular syndesmosis in 3 patients.In the buttress plate group,we detected toe flexion contracture in 4 patients,and uncomfortable feeling in ankle motion in 7 patients.At the final follow-up,X-rays and CT scans in the 2 groups showed no obvious post-traumatic osteoarthritis of the ankle.There were no significant differences between the 2 groups regarding the AOFAS scores at 6 and 12 months postoperation and the final follow-up(P ＞ 0.05);the AOFAS scores at the final follow-up for all the patients were significantly different from those at 6 and 12 months postoperation (P ＜ 0.05).At the final follow-up,there were no significant differences between the 2 groups regarding ROMs of dorsal flexion,plantar flexion,varus or valgus (P ＞ 0.05).Conclusions As there are no significant differences between the percutaneous cannulated lag screws and posterior buttress plate in AOFAS score and ROM of the ankle after fixation for posterior malleolar fractures,the 2 fixation methods can both achieve good clinical outcomes.Fixation with cannulated lag screws has advantages of indirect reduction and minimal invasion but also a disadvantage of uncertain quality of reduction;fixation with buttress plates has an advantage of anatomical reduction under direct vision but also shortcomings of relatively large invasion and high cost.

Comparison of buttress plate and cannulated screw in the treatment of anteromedial coronoid fracture with elbow posteromedial rotatory instability

Comparison of Different Treatment Approaches for Coronoid Process Fracture in Terrible Triad Injury: a Multicenter, Randomized Controlled Study.

A Comparison of the Clinical Effect of Two Fixation Methods on Hoffa Fractures

Clinical comparison of the over-the-top and flexor carpi ulnaris split approaches for the treatment of anteromedial facet fracture of the coronoid process

Plate Fixation Through an Anterior Approach for Coronoid Process Fractures

Biomechanical comparison of two internal fixation methods for AO type A3 fractures of distal femur

Biomechanical evaluation of internal fixation of different anterior canulated screws for the treatment of type odontoid fracture

Plate fixation through an anterior approach for coronoid process fractures: A retrospective case series and a literature review.

Intra-osteal fixation of comminuted coronoid process fracture with mini plate for the treatment of complex elbow fracture

Influence of the Proximal Screws of Buttress Plates on the Stability of Vertical Femoral Neck Fractures: a Finite Element Analysis

Biomechanical comparison of different internal fixation devices for transversely unstable Mason type II radial head fractures

Highly extensile approach for comminuted ulna coronoid process fractures with mini-plate fixation: a case series of 31 patients

Treatment of coronoid process fractures via the anteromedial approach

Biomechanical Analysis of Various Fixations for the Posterolateral Shearing Tibial Plateau Fracture

Comparison of plate versus screw internal fixation in the treatment of posterior malleolar fracture: A systematic review and meta-analysis

Comparison of cannulated lag screw versus buttress plate fixation for posterior malleolar fractures

Biomechanical comparison of two screw fixations in treatment of tibial plateau fractures ZHANG

A Biomechanical Evaluation of Different Fixation Strategies for Posterolateral Fragments in Tibial Plateau Fractures and Introduction of the 'magic Screw'

Combined fixation via anterior and posterior approach for treatment of ulnar coronoid frac-ture of O′Driscoll type ⅢB

A Locking Plate Designed With Cluster of Head Screws Would Be Biomechanically Superior Than Conventional Buttress Plate For The Fixation of Posteromedial Tibial Plateau Fractures: A Computational Assessment

Comparison of double mini locking plate and anatomical locking plate in the treatment of comminuted olecranon fracture