Free-energy measuring nanopore device

Momčilo Gavrilov,Jinghang Zhang,Olivia Yang,Taekjip Ha
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/physreve.109.024404
IF: 2.707
2024-02-11
Physical Review E
Abstract:Free energies (FEs) in molecular sciences can be used to quantify the stability of folded molecules. In this article, we introduce nanopores for measuring FEs. We pull DNA hairpin-forming molecules through a nanopore, measure work, and estimate the FE change in the slow limit, and with the Jarzynski fluctuation theorem (FT) at fast pulling times. We also pull our molecule with optical tweezers, compare it to nanopores, and explore how sampling single molecules from equilibrium or a folded ensemble affects the FE estimate via the FT. The nanopore experiment helps us address and overcome the conceptual problem of equilibrium sampling in single-molecule pulling experiments. Only when molecules are sampled from an equilibrium ensemble do nanopore and tweezer FE estimates mutually agree. We demonstrate that nanopores are very useful tools for comparing FEs of two molecules at finite times and we propose future applications. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevE.109.024404 Published by the American Physical Society under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International license. Further distribution of this work must maintain attribution to the author(s) and the published article's title, journal citation, and DOI. Published by the American Physical Society
physics, fluids & plasmas, mathematical
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper primarily aims to address the following key issues: 1. **Development of new free energy measurement tools**: Researchers introduce a new device based on nanopores for directly measuring free energy changes (FE) at the molecular level. This technology can measure the work done by pulling DNA hairpin structures through nanopores and further estimate the changes in free energy. 2. **Comparison of different experimental methods**: The paper also compares the differences in measuring free energy using nanopore technology and optical tweezers technology. Special attention is given to how sampling molecules from equilibrium and folded state ensembles affects free energy estimation. 3. **Addressing conceptual challenges**: The study addresses conceptual issues in single-molecule stretching experiments, particularly regarding how to correctly sample molecules from equilibrium ensembles to ensure the accuracy of free energy estimates. 4. **Overcoming practical challenges**: The nanopore device is designed to overcome some practical and technical challenges faced by existing single-molecule manipulation tools, such as sampling from equilibrium ensembles, reducing the impact of probes and handles, and extending the range of stretching rates. Specifically, the researchers conducted experiments by pulling a DNA hairpin structure containing 10 base pairs to verify that their nanopore device can accurately measure the work required and the changes in free energy during the unfolding process. Additionally, they compared the performance of nanopore technology and optical tweezers technology in these measurements and discussed the importance of sampling from equilibrium and folded state ensembles. When sampling from equilibrium ensembles, the free energy estimates obtained by both techniques are close, while sampling from folded state ensembles leads to deviations in the estimates. In summary, this paper proposes a novel method for accurately measuring free energy changes at the molecular level, experimentally validates the effectiveness and accuracy of this method, and provides a comparative analysis of the differences and advantages of traditional optical tweezers technology.