Price-Volume Relationship in Bitcoin Futures ETF Market: An Information Perspective

Xudong Wang,Xiaofeng Hui

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1155/2024/8066742

IF: 1.4

2024-04-01

Discrete Dynamics in Nature and Society

Abstract:Bitcoin futures exchange-traded funds (ETFs) are recent innovations in cryptocurrency investment. This article studies the price-volume relationship in this market from an information perspective. We first propose effective mutual information which has better estimation accuracy to analyze the contemporaneous relationship. Using half-hourly trading data of the world's largest Bitcoin futures ETF, we find that trading volume changes and returns contain information about each other and are contemporaneously dependent. Then, we employ effective transfer entropy to examine the intertemporal relationship. The results show that there exists information transfer from volume changes to returns in most of our sample period, suggesting the presence of return predictability and market inefficiency. However, information transfer in the opposite direction occurs much less frequently, and the amount is typically smaller.

mathematics, interdisciplinary applications,multidisciplinary sciences

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores the relationship between price and trading volume in the Bitcoin futures exchange-traded fund (ETF) market. Specifically, the study attempts to address the following questions:

1. **Price-Volume Relationship**: The paper aims to study the relationship between price and trading volume in the Bitcoin futures ETF market from an information theory perspective. The researchers propose Effective Mutual Information (EMI), an improved estimation method, to analyze the relationship between contemporaneous price and trading volume.

2. **Information Transfer**: By using Effective Transfer Entropy (ETE) to quantify the transfer of information over different time points. This method can be used to detect the impact of past trading volume changes on the prediction of future returns.

3. **Market Efficiency**: The study also explores whether these information transfer patterns indicate some form of market inefficiency. If market prices do not fully reflect all available information, there may be predictability in future returns.

4. **Directionality of Causality**: The study also focuses on the direction of information flow, i.e., whether changes in trading volume can better predict changes in returns, or vice versa.

Through an empirical analysis of half-hour trading data from the world's largest Bitcoin futures ETF—ProShares Bitcoin Strategy ETF (BITO), the study finds:

- **Contemporaneous Dependence**: There is a certain amount of information sharing between BITO's returns and changes in trading volume, indicating a contemporaneous dependence between the two.

- **Information Transfer**: During most sample periods, the information transfer from changes in trading volume to returns is more significant, suggesting that past changes in trading volume help predict future returns, and the existence of this predictive ability may indicate market inefficiency.

In summary, this paper provides new insights into the price-volume relationship in the Bitcoin futures ETF market by proposing new information measurement methods and applying these methods to actual financial data.