Calling the question: what is mammalian transgenerational epigenetic inheritance?

Hasan Khatib,Jessica Townsend,Melissa A. Konkel,Gabi Conidi,Julia A. Hasselkus
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/15592294.2024.2333586
2024-03-27
Epigenetics
Abstract:While transgenerational epigenetic inheritance has been extensively documented in plants, nematodes, and fruit flies, its existence in mammals remains controversial. Several factors have contributed to this debate, including the lack of a clear distinction between intergenerational and transgenerational epigenetic inheritance (TEI), the inconsistency of some studies, the potential confounding effects of in-utero vs. epigenetic factors, and, most importantly, the biological challenge of epigenetic reprogramming. Two waves of epigenetic reprogramming occur: in the primordial germ cells and the developing embryo after fertilization, characterized by global erasure of DNA methylation and remodelling of histone modifications. Consequently, TEI can only occur if specific genetic regions evade this reprogramming and persist through embryonic development. These challenges have revived the long-standing debate about the possibility of inheriting acquired traits, which has been strongly contested since the Lamarckian and Darwinian eras. As a result, coupled with the absence of universally accepted criteria for transgenerational epigenetic studies, a vast body of literature has emerged claiming evidence of TEI. Therefore, the goal of this study is to advocate for establishing fundamental criteria that must be met for a study to qualify as evidence of TEI. We identified five criteria based on the consensus of studies that critically evaluated TEI. To assess whether published original research papers adhere to these criteria, we examined 80 studies that either claimed or were cited as supporting TEI. The findings of this analysis underscore the widespread confusion in this field and highlight the urgent need for a unified scientific consensus on TEI requirements.
genetics & heredity,biochemistry & molecular biology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **Does transgenerational epigenetic inheritance (TEI) in mammals exist, and how to define and verify this phenomenon?** ### Background and Problems 1. **Controversy over Transgenerational Epigenetic Inheritance**: - Although transgenerational epigenetic inheritance has been widely documented in plants, nematodes, and Drosophila, its existence in mammals remains controversial. - Reasons for the controversy include: - The blurred boundary between intergenerational epigenetic inheritance and transgenerational epigenetic inheritance. - Inconsistent research results. - The potential confounding effects of in - utero environmental factors and epigenetic factors. - Most importantly, the epigenetic reprogramming challenges faced by organisms. Two extensive epigenetic reprogramming events occur during the germ cell and embryonic development of mammals, which means that specific gene regions must escape this reprogramming to achieve transgenerational epigenetic inheritance. 2. **Biological Challenges of Epigenetic Reprogramming**: - The first reprogramming occurs in primordial germ cells (PGCs). - The second reprogramming occurs during the early embryonic development after fertilization. - These two reprogramming events restore totipotency by globally erasing DNA methylation and remodeling histone modifications. Therefore, only specific gene regions that can escape this reprogramming and persist until the later stages of embryonic development may achieve transgenerational epigenetic inheritance. 3. **Lack of Unified Standards**: - Currently, there is a lack of generally accepted standards for transgenerational epigenetic research, resulting in a large number of literatures claiming to have evidence of TEI, but the actual quality varies. - Therefore, there is an urgent need to establish a set of clear standards to evaluate which studies can be regarded as valid evidence for TEI. ### Research Objectives - **Establish Research Standards for Transgenerational Epigenetic Inheritance**: Based on the consensus of existing research, the authors proposed five criteria that must be met to determine whether a study can be used as evidence for TEI. - **Evaluate the Compliance of Existing Studies**: The authors evaluated 80 studies that claimed or were cited as supporting TEI, checking whether these studies met the above - mentioned criteria. - **Reveal the Chaotic Situation in the Field**: The analysis results showed that many studies failed to fully meet all criteria, highlighting the widespread confusion in this field and emphasizing the urgency of reaching scientific consensus. ### Conclusion This study aims to promote a clearer understanding and further research in this field by proposing clear TEI research standards. At the same time, through the systematic evaluation of existing literatures, it reveals the problems and deficiencies in current research and provides guidance for future research.