Challenging care deficits

A. Gallagher

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/0969733012472285

IF: 3.344

2013-02-01

Nursing Ethics

Abstract:This is the first Editorial of 2013, marking the beginning of the journal’s 20th Anniversary year. This is a time to take stock of our achievements and to consider what our priorities should be in the coming year. We have achieved a good deal in terms of the quality of research, scholarship and educational innovations in health-care ethics. Media and research reports from around the world remind us, however, that there is still work to do to fully understand what contributes to, and reduces, care deficits. At the time of writing, the UK Patients Association published its fourth report with the headline ‘Culture of NHS Care remains unchallenged and unchanged’. The Care Quality Commission State of Care Report 2011/12 revealed that 10% of hospitals in England did not treat people with the respect they deserve, 15% of social care services did not respect people and 23% of services did not have ‘adequate staffing levels’. The Willis Commission on nurse education found that, contrary to the beliefs of some, there were ‘no shortcomings found in nurse education that could be directly responsible for poor standards of care or a decline in care standards’. My recent experiences of local, national and international initiatives suggest that many individuals and groups are highly motivated to address deficits and improve care. There is then some cause for optimism as many able people are engaged in finding solutions and many resources and strategies exist to enhance our understanding and sensitivity. Political action is clearly also necessary. An invitation to a special event at one of our local hospitals enabled me to encounter the work of the Tutu Foundation and to hear an address by Archbishop Desmond Tutu. The Foundation emphasises ubuntu, a value that refers to human interdependence and to an understanding of our common humanity. Archbishop Tutu is quoted as saying, ‘I am, because you are. How I behave impacts not only on me but also [on] others around me because we all belong together’. In his address to hospital staff, Archbishop Tutu emphasised the importance of care, dignity, compassion and generosity. He also highlighted the privilege of providing care, for example, giving a person who is dependent on you water to drink to quench their thirst. Archbishop Tutu is also a member of the Elders – a group of global leaders committed to human rights and humanitarian activity. Being told by a person of his moral stature that such an activity is of value reaffirms the dignity of nursing and other health professions. I was privileged to attend an ethics of care conference in Utrecht in November, organised by Professor Frans Vosman and colleagues. This brought together philosophers, social scientists and health professionals who are actively engaged in developing philosophical and empirical work in relation to the ethics of care. There were some fine examples of philosophical analyses that clarified central concepts such as care, dignity, vulnerability, attentiveness and sensitivity. Old debates were reopened regarding the relationship between care and justice. There was recognition of the value of multidisciplinary research in this area and