Abstract:Context In the exercise of his practice, the psychiatrist is commonly called upon to assess the suicidal risk of a patient and may, under the circumstances, engage his professional liability and become the subject of a civil suit in the event of the death of the patient. Despite the existence of guidelines and tools for the assessment and management of suicide risk, the practice often remains unstandardized. Few studies have focused on the assessment and management of this risk from a legal perspective. Some knowledge of case law could be useful to psychiatrists in making future decisions, both from a medico-legal point of view and to improve the care offered. Objectives This article aims to study the civil liability of the psychiatrist following the suicide of a patient by analyzing Canadian case law from a perspective of continuous improvement of practice with particular attention to the assessment and management of suicide risk. Method A systematic review of the judgments was carried out on CanLII.org, a virtual library of Canadian legal information allowing access to the judgments rendered by the courts of first instance, the Courts of Appeal as well as those of the Supreme Court of Canada. The search strategy consisted in using the key words "suicide," "psychiatrie," "faute" and "responsabilité" as well as their English translation to retain the recourses where a judgment was rendered by the court and where at least one psychiatrist acted as a defendant or co-defendant following the suicide of a patient. Results Nine judgments met our inclusion criteria. Since elements were of interest for our research question, it seemed wise to us to also include three decisions where the patient did not die of his suicidal attempt but kept significant sequelae. The analysis of the judgments made it possible to identify the alleged faults most often reproached to the psychiatrist by the plaintiff and to present the usual position of the courts, and the arguments which underlie them. The alleged faults can be grouped into three categories: an assessment of the suicide risk deemed faulty, a management of the suicide risk by supervisory measures deemed faulty and an omission to have used legal custody measures when they should have been applied. In nearly all cases, Canadian courts render a decision in favor of the psychiatrist, demonstrating sensitivity to the reality of psychiatrists' practice. The recommendations resulting from our analysis of Canadian case law support the guidelines of the American Psychiatric Association and the Ontario Hospital Association practice guidelines for suicide risk assessment and management, particularly in terms of the content of evaluation, specific moments of re-evaluation and documentation. Conclusion Knowledge of Canadian case law on civil liability for the suicide of a patient represents an additional asset for the practice of responsible and quality psychiatry.

A cell wall proteo-heteroglycan from Piricularia oryzae: isolation and partial structure.

Concurrent hepatic and ruptured renal angiomyolipoma in tuberous sclerosis complex.

Effects of rotation discipline on medical student grades in obstetrics and gynecology throughout the academic year.

Medical Professional Liability in Obstetrics and Gynecology: A Pilot Study of Criminal Proceedings in the Public Prosecutor's Office at the Court of Rome

[Is a duodenogastric reflux of pathogenic significance?].

Physician-Patient Relationship, Assisted Suicide and the Italian Constitutional Court

The Protection of Health in the Care and Trust Relationship between Doctor and Patient: Competence, Professional Autonomy and Responsibility of the Doctor and Decision-Making Autonomy of the Patient

The Physician-Assisted Suicide Pathway in Italy: Ethical Assessment and Safeguard Approaches

A case of suicide of psychiatric patient in the Sicilian hospital: accidental or professional liability of "top management"?

Mental health care in Italy: Basaglia's ashes in the wind of the crisis of the last decade

The effect of azalomycin F on Ca2+ homeostasis in Trichoderma viride and Saccharomyces cerevisiae.

Death of the suicide law: A changing standard of liability for clinicians

[The civil liability of the psychiatrist in Canada following the suicide of a patient: An analysis based on case law]

The crystal structure of human procathepsin K.

Kx, a quantitatively minor protein from human erythrocytes, is palmitoylated in vivo.

[Which way ahead for psychiatry? Identity, competence and cooperation--challenges of the 21st century]

[Involuntary hospitalization and treatment: the interface between psychiatry and law]

Musculoskeletal manifestations in inflammatory bowel disease.

[Analysis of changes in legislation on the provision of psychiatric care]

Core topics in forensic psychiatry

The closing of forensic psychiatric hospitals in Italy: Determinants, current status and future perspectives. A scoping review