Better to demedicalise rather than further medicalise and bureaucratise death

Richard Smith

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.q2719

2024-12-05

BMJ

Abstract:I'm in favour of assisted dying, and I was pleased to see the House of Commons in the UK have a sober, rational, respectful debate on one aspect of death and dying, assisted dying. Death—"that distinguished thing," as Henry James called it—encourages seriousness, which is one of its many virtues. But the claim I see on the front of the Daily Express, "Now future generations will be spared ordeal we suffer" is nothing short of absurd. The option of an assisted death will be taken up by some people, mostly well to-do people used to having control over their lives, but assisted dying will by no means solve many people dying badly nor our society, like most wealthy societies, having what the Lancet Commission on the Value of Death (which I cochaired) called an "unhealthy relationship with death."One of the biggest problems with death and dying is that they have...

medicine, general & internal