Nutritional changes in trees during drought‐induced mortality: A comprehensive meta‐analysis and a field study
Peng He,Jordi Sardans,Xiaoyu Wang,Chengcang Ma,Liang Man,Josep Peñuelas,Xingguo Han,Yong Jiang,Mai‐He Li
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/gcb.17133
IF: 11.6
2024-01-10
Global Change Biology
Abstract:The impact of the nutritional status of trees on their ability to withstand drought‐induced mortality remains inconclusive. Our meta‐analysis indicated that tissue phosphorus (P), potassium (K), iron (Fe), and copper (Cu) concentrations declined obviously with decreasing tree vitality, implying their roles as a potential early‐warning signal for impending tree mortality. However, our field study showed no significant differences in tissue nutrient concentrations among Scots pine trees of different vitality. This discrepancy could be explained by several critical variables including experimental design types, tree ontogenetic stages, organ types, phylum, leaf life traits, forest biomes, and soil types. Both macronutrients and micronutrients are essential for tree growth and development through participating in various ecophysiological processes. However, the impact of the nutritional status of trees on their ability to withstand drought‐induced mortality remains inconclusive. We thus conducted a comprehensive meta‐analysis, compiling data on 11 essential nutrients from 44 publications (493 independent observations). Additionally, a field study was conducted on Pinus sylvestris L. trees with varying drought‐induced vitality loss in the "Visp" forest in southern Switzerland. No consistent decline in tree nutritional status was observed during tree mortality. The meta‐analysis revealed significantly lower leaf potassium (K), iron (Fe), and copper (Cu) concentrations with tree mortality. However, the field study showed no causal relationships between nutritional levels and the vitality status of trees. This discrepancy is mainly attributed to the intrinsic differences in the two types of experimental designs and the ontogenetic stages of target trees. Nutrient reductions preceding tree mortality were predominantly observed in non‐field conditions, where the study was conducted on seedlings and saplings with underdeveloped root systems. It limits the nutrient uptake capacity of these young trees during drought. Furthermore, tree nutritional responses are also influenced by many variables. Specifically, (a) leaf nutrients are more susceptible to drought stress than other organs; (b) reduced tree nutrient concentrations are more prevalent in evergreen species during drought‐induced mortality; (c) of all biomes, Mediterranean forests are most vulnerable to drought‐induced nutrient deficiencies; (d) soil types affect the direction and extent of tree nutritional responses. We identified factors that influence the relationship between tree nutritional status and drought survival, and proposed potential early‐warning indicators of impending tree mortality, for example, decreased K concentrations with declining vitality. These findings contribute to our understanding of tree responses to drought and provide practical implications for forest management strategies in the context of global change.
environmental sciences,biodiversity conservation,ecology