Abstract:The central problem of the article is the paradox in the history of Newton’s mechanics: prominent researchers of the genesis of the Principia did not believe Newton’s words about the origin of the idea of universal gravity. They did not believe that he could have come up with this idea as early as 1666, considering circular orbits, and believed that Newton invented the story of the falling apple. The article proposes a “subjunctive” scenario leading to the law of universal gravity and feasible at the level of Galileo’s knowledge and skills in 1611. The basis for such a scenario is the description of a thought experiment in Newton’s manuscript “The System of the World”, preceding the creation of Principia. The proposed reconstruction helps to consider and clarify the concept of “modern physics”, the birth of which was the main event of the Scientific Revolution of the XVI–XVII centuries. The traditional understanding reduces the essence of modern physics to a reliance on experience and on the language of mathematics. Such a definition, however, is not sufficient. The geometry of Euclid and the physics of Archimedes were mathematically perfect, and their axioms were based on objective experience. Despite the importance of the tools of mathematics and experiment, the key innovation of modern physics has become the belief in the hidden fundamental laws of the Universe and in the right of the researcher to invent invisible, “illogical”, “absurd” concepts and postulates, experimentally verifiable only together with the theory based on them. This postulate of fundamental cognitive optimism combines bold ingenuity with a humble need for empirical verification.

A New Scientific Revolution at the Horizon?

Prospects of relativistic astrophysics: Viewpoints on the most influential journey

The revolution in physics of the early Nineteenth century revisited in the context of science-and-society interaction

Visions of Revolutions: Microphysics and Cosmophysics in the 1930s

History of the NeoClassical Interpretation of Quantum and Relativistic Physics

Four revolutions in physics and the second quantum revolution -- a unification of force and matter by quantum information

100 Years of Relativistic Cosmology (1917-2017). Part I: From Origins to the Discovery of Universal Expansion (1929)

The clouds of physics and Einstein's last query: Can quantum mechanics be derived from general relativity?

The Counterintuitive Universe

Essay: Quantum Sensing with Atomic, Molecular, and Optical Platforms for Fundamental Physics

Can relativity be considered complete ? From Newtonian nonlocality to quantum nonlocality and beyond

Could Galileo Discover the Law of Universal Gravitation in 1611, Was There Newton’s Apple and What Is “Modern Physics”?.

The relativity revolution from the perspective of historical epistemology

Historical Approach to Physics according to Kant, Einstein, and Hegel

Einstein'S Impact on Theoretical Physics

The sounds of science—a symphony for many instruments and voices: part II

The Physics of Quantum 2.0: Challenges in understanding Quantum Matter

Uncertain for A Century: Quantum Mechanics and The Dilemma of Interpretation

Some Implications of the Cosmological Constant to Fundamental Physics

Observations in Quantum Cosmology

The sounds of science a symphony for many instruments and voices part II