Self–other agreement on multidimensional self-concept ratings: Factor analysis and multitrait–multimethod analysis.

Herbert W Marsh, Jennifer Barnes, Dennis Hocevar
1985-11-01
Abstract:College students were asked to complete the Self-Description Questionnaire III (SDQ III; Marsh & O'Niell, 1984) and to ask the person who knew them the best to complete the SDQ III as if they were the person who had given the particular student the survey. The purposes of the study are to examine psychometric properties of the SDQ III, to determine the ability of an external observer to accurately infer multidimensional self-concepts, and to describe new methodological approaches to this type of study. Separate factor analyses of both self-ratings and responses by significant others identified the 13 dimensions of self-concept that the SDQ III was designed to measure. For each set, the internal consistences of the 13 scales were high, whereas the average correlation among the factors was close to zero. Self-other agreement was quite high (mean r= 0.58), demonstrating that significant others are able to accurately …
What problem does this paper attempt to address?