Abstract:Composting of solid waste can be associated with a loss of the agronomic value (nutrient loss), as well as a source of environmental impact through the emission of the greenhouse gases (GHG) nitrous oxide (N2O) and methane (CH4) and volatilization of ammonia (NH3). Additives have been considered as a useful option to mitigate these environmental emissions, but the wider effects of using different additives on multiple gas emissions is still uncertain. Here, a global meta-analysis was conducted using 105 studies with 303 paired comparisons, to quantify the impact of different additives on NH3 and GHG emissions, considering different composting feedstock properties. On average, additives reduced the total nitrogen (TN) loss (46.4%), NH3 (44.5%), N2O (44.6%) and CH4 (68.5%) emissions, and total GHG emissions expressed as global warming potential (GWP) (54.2%) during composting. Chemical, physical and microbial additives all significantly reduced TN loss and NH3 emission; however, the strongest effect was observed for chemical additives under the condition of low moisture content (≤65%), low C/N ratios (≤20) or alkalinity (pH > 7.5). Specifically, PO43− and Mg2+ salt had the greatest mean mitigation for TN loss (68.0%) and NH3 emission (62.0%). In contrast, physical additives (e.g. biochar and zeolite) were more effective at reducing the total GHG emissions (67.2%) compared with chemical additives because of the greater mitigation of N2O emission. Low moisture content (≤65%) or low C/N ratios (≤20) enhanced the effectiveness of chemical additives in reducing TN loss and NH3 emission. Physical additives were suggested to be more effective in reducing N2O emission at low moisture content (≤65%) or high C/N ratios (>20 to ≤ 30). The magnitude of the mitigation of TN loss and NH3 emission increased as the dosage rate of PO43− and Mg2+ salt/superphosphate increased between 0 and 20%. This meta-analysis suggests that an optimized combination of chemical and physical additives tailored to feedstock characteristics and application dosage may be a promising approach for the synergistic mitigation of NH3 and GHG emissions.

Sulfuric acid modified expanded vermiculite cover for reducing ammonia emissions from animal slurry storage

The influence of using different types of modified vermiculite cover on ammonia mitigation from animal slurry storage: The role of sulfuric acid

NH3 and N2O emission and nitrogen loss rate from biogas liquid produced by pig slurry after topdressing on vegetable fields

Reducing Aerosol and Ammonia Emission in Post-Combustion CO2 Capture: Additives As Key Solutions

Mitigation of ammonia and methane emissions with manure amendments during storage of cattle slurry

Ammonia mitigation effects from the cow housing and manure storage chain on the nitrogen and carbon footprints of a typical dairy farm system on the North China Plain

Effects of self-produced lactic fermentation (SPLF) on GHG and VSC emissions during swine slurry storage

A Case Study of Effects of Sulfuric Acid Spray on Ammonia and Odor Emissions from Swine Manure Composting

Slow pyrolysis liquid in reducing NH3 emissions from cattle slurry - Impacts on plant growth and soil organisms

Slurry Acidification as a Solution to Minimize Ammonia Emissions from the Combined Application of Animal Manure and Synthetic Fertilizer in No-Tillage

Effects of Acidification During Storage on Emissions of Methane, Ammonia, and Hydrogen Sulfide from Digested Pig Slurry

Ammonia Mitigation Measures Reduce Greenhouse Gas Emissions from an Integrated Manure-Cropland System

Mitigation of Ammonia Emissions from Cattle Manure Slurry by Tannins and Tannin-Based Polymers

Study on the reduction of NH3 volatilization from broiler litter through the promotion of nitrification

Influence of Treatments and Covers on NH3 Emissions from Dairy Cow and Buffalo Manure Storage

Biochar amendment to cattle slurry reduces NH3 emissions during storage without risk of higher NH3 emissions after soil application of the solid fraction

New horizons in the application of a neglected biomass pyrolysis byproduct: A marked simultaneous decrease in ammonia and carbon dioxide emissions

Mitigation of ammonia, nitrous oxide and methane emissions during solid waste composting with different additives: A meta-analysis

Responses of CH4, N2O, and NH3 emissions to different slurry pH values of 5.5-10.0: Characteristics and mechanisms

NH3, N2O, and NO emissions from digested pig slurry stored under different temperatures: Characteristics and microbial mechanisms

Co-application of biogas slurry and hydrothermal carbonization aqueous phase substitutes urea as the nitrogen fertilizer and mitigates ammonia volatilization from paddy soil