Abstract:The choice of appropriate physical quantities to characterize the biological effects of ionizing radiation has evolved over time coupled with advances in scientific understanding. The basic hypothesis in radiation dosimetry is that the energy deposited by ionizing radiation initiates all the consequences of exposure in a biological sample (e.g., DNA damage, reproductive cell death). Physical quantities defined to characterize energy deposition have included dose, a measure of the mean energy imparted per unit mass of the target, and linear energy transfer (LET), a measure of the mean energy deposition per unit distance that charged particles traverse in a medium. The primary advantage of using the "dose and LET" physical system is its relative simplicity, especially for presenting and recording results. Inclusion of additional information such as the energy spectrum of charged particles renders this approach adequate to describe the biological effects of large dose levels from homogeneous sources. The primary disadvantage of this system is that it does not provide a unique description of the stochastic nature of radiation interactions. We and others have used dose-averaged LET (LET d ) as a correlative physical quantity to the relative biological effectiveness (RBE) of proton beams. This approach is based on established experimental findings that proton RBE increases with LET d . However, this approach might not be applicable to intensity-modulated proton therapy or other applications in which the proton energy spectrum is highly heterogeneous. In the current study, we irradiated cancer cells with scanning proton beams with identical LET d (3.4 keV/μm) but arising from two different proton energy/LET spectra (a narrow spectrum in group 1 and a widespread heterogeneous spectrum in group 2). Clonogenic survival after irradiation revealed significant differences in RBE at any cell surviving fraction: e.g., at a surviving fraction of 0.1, the RBE was 0.97 ± 0.03 in group 1 and 1.16 ± 0.04 in group 2 ( p ≤0.01), validating our hypothesis that LET d alone may not adequately indicate proton RBE. Further analysis showed that microdosimetric spectrum (the probability density function of the stochastic physical quantity lineal energy y ) was helpful for interpreting observed differences in biological effects. However, more accurate use of microdosimetric spectrum to quantify RBE requires a cell line–specific mechanistic model.

Response of human lymphocytes to proton radiation of 60 MeV compared to 250 kV X-rays by the cytokinesis-block micronucleus assay

Investigation of DNA Damage and Cell-Cycle Distribution in Human Peripheral Blood Lymphocytes under Exposure to High Doses of Proton Radiotherapy

[The preliminary report of a registration clinical trial of proton and heavy ion irradiation].

Dose-response of micronuclei frequency in lymphoblast cells irradiated with different LET rays and combination of α-particles and γ-rays

Detailed analysis of the cell-inactivation mechanism by accelerated protons and light ions

Acute normal tissue responses in a murine model following fractionated irradiation of the head and neck with protons or X-rays

Impact of Proton Irradiation Depending on Breast Cancer Subtype in Patient-Derived Cell Lines

Peripheral blood lymphocytes differ in DNA damage response after exposure to X-rays with different physical properties

High-LET Carbon and Iron Ions Elicit a Prolonged and Amplified p53 Signaling and Inflammatory Response Compared to low-LET X-Rays in Human Peripheral Blood Mononuclear Cells

Cellular Response to Proton Irradiation: A Simulation Study with TOPAS-nBio

Interpreting the biological effects of protons as a function of physical quantity: linear energy transfer or microdosimetric lineal energy spectrum?

Early Effects of Low Dose 12C6+ Ion or X-ray Irradiation on Human Peripheral Blood Lymphocytes

An in vitro Study on Dose Effect Relationship of Micronuclei in Human Peripheral Lymphocytes Induced by Different Radiation Rays

DNA double-strand breaks in cancer cells as a function of proton linear energy transfer and its variation in time

Radiation-Induced Toxicity Risks in Photon Versus Proton Therapy for Synchronous Bilateral Breast Cancer

Dose Response of Micronuclei Induced by Combination Radiation of Α-Particles and Γ-Rays in Human Lymphoblast Cells

Clustered DNA Damage Patterns after Proton Therapy Beam Irradiation Using Plasmid DNA

The differential immunological impact of photon vs proton radiation therapy in high grade lymphopenia

DNA Damage Response in Prostate Cancer Cells by Proton Microbeam Irradiation

Renormalization of radiobiological response functions by energy loss fluctuations and complexities in chromosome aberration induction: deactivation theory for proton therapy from cells to tumor control

Effects of cellular radioresponse on therapeutic helium-, carbon-, oxygen-, and neon-ion beams: a simulation study