Abstract:BackgroundCertain manipulations, such as testing oneself on newly learned word associations (recall), or the act of repeating a word during training (reproduction), can lead to better learning and retention relative to simply providing more exposure to the word (restudy). Such benefit has been observed for written words. Here, we test how these training manipulations affect learning of words presented aurally, when participants are required to produce these novel phonological forms in a recall task.MethodsParticipants (36 English-speaking adults) learned 27 pseudowords, which were paired with 27 unfamiliar pictures. They were given cued recall practice for 9 of the words, reproduction practice for another set of 9 words, and the remaining 9 words were restudied. Participants were tested on their recognition (3-alternative forced choice) and recall (saying the pseudoword in response to a picture) of these items immediately after training, and a week after training. Our hypotheses were that reproduction and restudy practice would lead to better learning immediately after training, but that cued recall practice would lead to better retention in the long term.ResultsIn all three conditions, recognition performance was extremely high immediately after training, and a week following training, indicating that participants had acquired associations between the novel pictures and novel words. In addition, recognition and cued recall performance was better immediately after training relative to a week later, confirming that participants forgot some words over time. However, results in the cued recall task did not support our hypotheses. Immediately after training, participants showed an advantage for cued Recall over the Restudy condition, but not over the Reproduce condition. Furthermore, there was no boost for the cued Recall condition over time relative to the other two conditions. Results from a Bayesian analysis also supported this null finding. Nonetheless, we found a clear effect of word length, with shorter words being better learned than longer words, indicating that our method was sufficiently sensitive to detect an impact of condition on learning.ConclusionsOur primary hypothesis about training conditions conferring specific advantages for production of novel words presented aurally, especially over long intervals, was not supported by this data. Although there may be practical reasons for preferring a particular method for training expressive vocabulary, no difference in effectiveness was detected when presenting words aurally: reproducing, recalling or restudying a word led to the same production accuracy.

The production effect in memory: a prominent mnemonic in children

Generation (not production) improves the fidelity of visual representations in picture naming

Singing Facilitates Word Learning and Memory

Give me enough time to rehearse: presentation rate modulates the production effect

An Investigation of Cross-Modality Effects in Implicit and Explicit Memory

Singing Does Not Necessarily Improve Memory More Than Reading Aloud

The effect of recall, reproduction, and restudy on word learning: a pre-registered study

Effectiveness of production and drawing as encoding techniques on recall using mixed- and pure-list designs

Production benefits on encoding are modulated by language experience: Less experience may help

The drawing effect: Evidence for reliable and robust memory benefits in free recall

Dissociable roles of neural pattern reactivation and transformation during recognition of words read aloud and silently: An MVPA study of the production effect

The Surprisingly Powerful Influence of Drawing on Memory

Bilingualism Influences How Articulation Enhances Verbal Encoding

Is Verbal Rehearsal Strategic? An Investigation into Overt Rehearsal of Nameable Pictures in 5- to 10-Year-Old Children

The maxispan procedure makes the phonological similarity effect disappear while increasing recall performance

Forming a stable memory representation in the first year of life: why imitation is more than child's play

Individual differences diminish the pretest effect under productive memory conditions

Phonetic Skills and Verbal Memory Capacity Predict Phonetic-based Word Learning: An Event-related Potential Study

ERPs and Oscillations During Encoding Predict Retrieval of Digit Memory in Superior Mnemonists

Mine, Mine, Mine: Self-Reference and Children’s Retention of Novel Words

Repetition suppression and repetition enhancement underlie auditory memory-trace formation in the human brain: an MEG study