Head-to-Head Comparison of DH3 HPV Test and HC2 Assay for Detection of High-Risk HPV Infection in Residual Cytology Samples from Cervical Cancer Screening Setting: Baseline and 3-Year Longitudinal Data

Yunfeng Fu,Xiao Li,Ying Li,Weiguo Lu,Xing Xie,Xinyu Wang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1128/spectrum.01570-21
IF: 3.7
2022-02-23
Microbiology Spectrum
Abstract:The benefits of testing for high-risk human papillomavirus (hrHPV) in cervical cancer screening have already been demonstrated. Hybrid Capture 2 (HC2) is the best validated HPV assay and has been considered the gold standard for hrHPV testing.
microbiology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to evaluate and compare the clinical performance of the DH3 HPV detection method and the HC2 detection method in high - risk HPV infection in cervical cancer screening. Specifically, the study aims to answer the following questions: 1. **Consistency between the two detection methods**: How consistent are the DH3 HPV detection method and the HC2 detection method in detecting high - risk HPV infection? Are there significant differences? 2. **Sensitivity and specificity**: Are the sensitivity and specificity of these two methods equivalent in detecting cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) grade 2 or higher (CIN2 +) and CIN grade 3 or higher (CIN3 +) lesions? 3. **Performance in long - term follow - up**: During the 3 - year follow - up period, do the two detection methods maintain consistent performance? 4. **Application potential in the primary screening strategy**: Can the DH3 HPV detection method replace the HC2 detection method in the primary screening strategy, especially when HPV16/18 genotyping is carried out simultaneously? ### Research background Cervical cancer is the fourth most common cancer among women worldwide. Almost all cervical cancers and their precursor lesions are caused by persistent high - risk human papillomavirus (hrHPV) infection. Hybrid Capture 2 (HC2) is currently one of the most commonly used high - risk HPV detection methods and is considered the gold standard. However, HC2 cannot distinguish between HPV16 and 18 and other high - risk types of HPV, which limits its application in cervical cancer screening. The DH3 HPV detection method is a new method based on the hybrid capture technique. It can detect 14 high - risk types of HPV and simultaneously perform HPV16/18 genotyping. Therefore, researchers hope to evaluate the potential advantages of the DH3 HPV detection method in cervical cancer screening by comparing these two methods. ### Main findings - **Consistency**: The overall consistency between the DH3 HPV detection method and the HC2 detection method is 99.2%, and the Kappa coefficient is 0.938, indicating a very high degree of agreement between the two. - **Sensitivity and specificity**: At baseline, the sensitivity of the DH3 HPV detection method for CIN2 + and CIN3 + is 98.67% and 97.78% respectively, which is equivalent to that of the HC2 detection method. There are also no significant differences in terms of specificity. - **Long - term follow - up**: During the 3 - year follow - up period, the sensitivity and specificity of the two detection methods for CIN2 + and CIN3 + remain consistent. - **Application in the primary screening strategy**: In the primary screening strategy, using the DH3 HPV detection method and triaging through HPV16/18 genotyping and/or liquid - based cytology (LBC) can significantly increase the immediate sensitivity to 92%, while the immediate sensitivity of the HC2 detection method through LBC triaging is only 74.67%. ### Conclusion The research results show that the DH3 HPV detection method is equivalent to the HC2 detection method in detecting high - risk HPV infection and identifying high - grade cervical lesions, and has potential advantages in the primary screening strategy, especially when HPV16/18 genotyping can be carried out simultaneously. Therefore, the DH3 HPV detection method can be regarded as an effective alternative to the HC2 detection method.