"Influencing the influencers:" a field experimental approach to promoting effective mental health communication on TikTok

Matt Motta,Yuning Liu,Amanda Yarnell
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-024-56578-1
IF: 4.6
2024-03-13
Scientific Reports
Abstract:A substantial body of social scientific research considers the negative mental health consequences of social media use on TikTok. Fewer, however, consider the potentially positive impact that mental health content creators ("influencers") on TikTok can have to improve health outcomes; including the degree to which the platform exposes users to evidence-based mental health communication. Our novel, influencer-led approach remedies this shortcoming by attempting to change TikTok creator content-producing behavior via a large, within-subject field experiment (N = 105 creators with a reach of over 16.9 million viewers; N = 3465 unique videos). Our randomly-assigned field intervention exposed influencers on the platform to either (a) asynchronous digital (.pdf) toolkits, or (b) both toolkits and synchronous virtual training sessions that aimed to promote effective evidence-based mental health communication (relative to a control condition, exposed to neither intervention). We find that creators treated with our asynchronous toolkits—and, in some cases, those also attending synchronous training sessions—were significantly more likely to (i) feature evidence-based mental health content in their videos and (ii) generate video content related to mental health issues. Moderation analyses further reveal that these effects are not limited to only those creators with followings under 2 million users. Importantly, we also document large system-level effects of exposure to our interventions; such that TikTok videos featuring evidence-based content received over half a million additional views in the post-intervention period in the study's treatment groups, while treatment group mental health content (in general) received over three million additional views. We conclude by discussing how simple, cost-effective, and influencer-led interventions like ours can be deployed at scale to influence mental health content on TikTok.
multidisciplinary sciences
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper aims to explore how to improve the quality and quantity of mental health information on TikTok by influencing mental health content creators (referred to as "influencers"), which may in turn improve users' mental health outcomes. The research background points out that while social media, especially TikTok, may have a negative impact on users' mental health, few studies have considered leveraging influencers on the platform to promote evidence-based mental health communication content to foster positive mental health effects. In light of this, the researchers designed a large-scale field experiment aimed at changing the video production behavior of these influencers, making them more inclined to post evidence-based mental health content. Specifically, the study selected 105 influential creators (covering over 16.9 million viewers) and randomly assigned them to receive different forms of interventions: one group received only a digital toolkit (asynchronous intervention), while the other group received the toolkit plus participated in synchronous virtual training sessions. The main goals of the study included assessing the extent to which influencers currently produce evidence-based mental health content and examining whether the research team could change their behavior through interventions to increase the output of such content. The results showed that the asynchronous toolkit intervention significantly increased the likelihood of influencers mentioning evidence-based core themes in their videos and increased the production of mental health-related content. Further analysis found that this effect existed even for influencers with fewer than 2 million followers. System-level analysis also indicated that evidence-based mental health content received over 500,000 additional views post-intervention, while the overall views of mental health content increased by over 3 million. In summary, the paper attempts to address the issue of how to effectively enhance the quality and quantity of mental health content on the TikTok platform and whether these improvements can be scaled up. The study proposes a cost-effective strategy—through simple asynchronous toolkit interventions, influencers' behavior can be significantly influenced, which may in turn have a positive impact on the mental health of a broad user base.