Normative and microeconomic models of voluntary childlessness.

Thomas Dietz

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/02732173.1984.9981719

Sociological Spectrum

Abstract: This paper employs microeconomic and normative variables rather than the more commonly used social psychological modesl to examine voluntary childlessness. The author uses religion, race, ruban versus sural residence, education, and region of residence as normative determinants of fertility; he hypothesizes that fewer Catholics will be childless and that urban dwellers, the well-educated, and those from the West, Midwest, and Northeast will be most likely to remain childless. Microeconomic theory, emphasizing the costs of children, assumes that income and fertility are directly related and that income and childlessness are inversely related. Because loss of wife's income is a greater factor than the direct costs of a child, childlessness should be more common when the wife's earning potential, or opportunity costs, is highest. In the microeconomic model, education is the most important determinant in the wife's opportunity costs. The findings indicate that husband's income is directly related to the first birth, and that wife's education (and opportunity costs) reduces the chances of a first birth. Microeconomic theory suggests that differences in child costs or in tastes could produce urban-rural, regional, or racial differences in childlessness. Demographic variables such as age, age at marriage, and marital duration also influence the likelihood of a first birth. The author uses data for 2182 intentionally childless black and white women, aged 20-34, from the 1965 National Fertility Survey to test his models. Study findings indicate that 1) marital duration greater than 15 years is the only significant demographic control variable, 2) normative variables generally meet expectations; only the coefficient for Catholicism is significant, and 3) financial satisfaction is positively associated with childlessness; husband's income is the only significant variable. Future research should 1) examine how Catholicism acts to discourage childlessness, 2) employ normative and microeconomic theories, and 3) examine data representative of the general population, even though childlessness in the samples may be rare.