Abstract:Abstract Background For finite samples with binary outcomes penalized logistic regression such as ridge logistic regression has the potential of achieving smaller mean squared errors (MSE) of coefficients and predictions than maximum likelihood estimation. There is evidence, however, that ridge logistic regression can result in highly variable calibration slopes in small or sparse data situations. Methods In this paper, we elaborate this issue further by performing a comprehensive simulation study, investigating the performance of ridge logistic regression in terms of coefficients and predictions and comparing it to Firth’s correction that has been shown to perform well in low-dimensional settings. In addition to tuned ridge regression where the penalty strength is estimated from the data by minimizing some measure of the out-of-sample prediction error or information criterion, we also considered ridge regression with pre-specified degree of shrinkage. We included ‘oracle’ models in the simulation study in which the complexity parameter was chosen based on the true event probabilities (prediction oracle) or regression coefficients (explanation oracle) to demonstrate the capability of ridge regression if truth was known. Results Performance of ridge regression strongly depends on the choice of complexity parameter. As shown in our simulation and illustrated by a data example, values optimized in small or sparse datasets are negatively correlated with optimal values and suffer from substantial variability which translates into large MSE of coefficients and large variability of calibration slopes. In contrast, in our simulations pre-specifying the degree of shrinkage prior to fitting led to accurate coefficients and predictions even in non-ideal settings such as encountered in the context of rare outcomes or sparse predictors. Conclusions Applying tuned ridge regression in small or sparse datasets is problematic as it results in unstable coefficients and predictions. In contrast, determining the degree of shrinkage according to some meaningful prior assumptions about true effects has the potential to reduce bias and stabilize the estimates.

Tractable Ridge Regression for Paired Comparisons

Ridge Regression for Paired Comparisons: A Tractable New Approach, with Application to Premier League Football

ROC Analysis for Paired Comparison Data

On Extending the Bradley-Terry Model to Accommodate Ties in Paired Comparison Experiments

Models for Paired Comparison Data: A Review with Emphasis on Dependent Data

Extended ordered paired comparison models with application to football data from German Bundesliga

A Bayesian approach to time-varying latent strengths in pairwise comparisons

Statistical inference for pairwise comparison models

The Bradly-Terry Regression Trunk approach for modelling preference data with small trees

Torsion of appendix epididymis.

The many routes to the ubiquitous Bradley-Terry model

A semi-automatic method to guide the choice of ridge parameter in ridge regression

A Bayesian Bradley-Terry model to compare multiple ML algorithms on multiple data sets

Hierarchical Bayesian Bradley-Terry for Applications in Major League Baseball

Improving pairwise comparison models using Empirical Bayes shrinkage

Estimation from Pairwise Comparisons: Sharp Minimax Bounds with Topology Dependence

Performance of bias‐correction methods for exposure measurement error using repeated measurements with and without missing data

Efficient computation of rankings from pairwise comparisons

Identifying a class of Ridge-type estimators in binary logistic regression models

Ranking with multiple types of pairwise comparisons

To tune or not to tune, a case study of ridge logistic regression in small or sparse datasets