Abstract:We study the effects of strategy-dependent time delays in deterministic and stochastic compartment models of the Snowdrift game. In replicator dynamics with two compartments, adults and kindergarten, augmented by death rates, stationary states of population sizes and strategy frequencies depend continuously on time delays represented by transition rates between compartments. In the corresponding birth-death Markov jump processes we observe the novel behavior, time delays are beneficial for the cooperation strategy.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to solve the problem of the impact of introducing strategy - dependent time delays in evolutionary game theory on population dynamics and strategy frequencies. Specifically, the research focuses on the following points:
1. **The impact of time delays on deterministic and stochastic compartment models**:
- In the classic Replicator Dynamics, it is usually assumed that the interactions between individuals are instantaneous and the effects are immediately apparent. However, in the real world, all processes require a certain amount of time. Therefore, the author introduced strategy - dependent time delays and studied their impact on the stationary states of population size and strategy frequencies.
- By combining the work of Tao and Cressman [5] and the compartment model proposed by Fic et al. [6], the author constructed a compartment model with mortality to simulate the evolution of a finite population under the limit of environmental carrying capacity.
2. **The impact of time delays on cooperation strategies**:
- The research found that in the deterministic model, time delays are not favorable to cooperation strategies, resulting in a smaller basin of attraction for cooperation strategies.
- However, in the stochastic model, time delays are instead favorable to cooperation strategies. Specifically, as the delay time increases, the frequency of cooperators also increases correspondingly. This phenomenon was not observed in the previous deterministic model.
3. **The impact of internal noise**:
- To explore the impact of internal noise, the author introduced birth - death Markov jump processes and obtained the expected values of population size and strategy frequencies through stochastic simulations.
- The results show that time delays have a positive impact on cooperation strategies in the stochastic model, which is different from the results in the deterministic model.
### Specific research content
- **Construction of compartment models**:
- Two compartments were introduced: Adults (A) and Kindergarten (K). Among them, individuals in the kindergarten cannot participate in the game, and only adults can participate and reproduce.
- The model considered the conversion rates from the kindergarten to adults, and these conversion rates depend on strategies, population size, and the time that individuals stay in the kindergarten.
- **Mathematical models**:
- Differential equations were set to describe the changes in the number of individuals in adults and kindergartens. For example, for the cooperation strategy \(C\) and the defection strategy \(D\), there are the following equations:
\[
\frac{dn_A^C}{dt}=\frac{n_K^C}{\tau_C}-\beta_A N_A n_A^C
\]
\[
\frac{dn_A^D}{dt}=\frac{n_K^D}{\tau_D}-\beta_A N_A n_A^D
\]
\[
\frac{dn_K^C}{dt}=n_A^C\pi_C-\beta_K N_K n_K^C-\frac{n_K^C}{\tau_C}
\]
\[
\frac{dn_K^D}{dt}=n_A^D\pi_D-\beta_K N_K n_K^D-\frac{n_K^D}{\tau_D}
\]
- **Numerical simulations and analysis**:
- Through numerical solutions and stochastic simulations, the impact of different time delays on population size and strategy frequencies was studied. The results show that when the time delays of the two strategies are equal, the total population size decreases, but the frequency of the cooperation strategy increases.
### Conclusion
This study reveals the different behaviors of time delays in deterministic and stochastic models. In particular, in the stochastic model, time delays have a positive impact on cooperation strategies. This provides a new perspective for understanding the time - delay effects in evolutionary games and emphasizes the importance of internal noise in evolutionary dynamics.