A New Parameterization of Photoinhibition For Phytoplankton

Mohammad M. Amirian,Zoe V. Finkel,Emmanuel Devred,Andrew J. Irwin

2024-12-24

Abstract:Mathematical models of photosynthesis-irradiance relationships in phytoplankton are used to compute integrated water-column photosynthetic rates and predict primary production in ecosystem models. Models typically ignore an important phenomenon observed in most experiments: photosynthetic rate is an approximately constant maximum value over a range of irradiances until photoinhibition leads to decreasing photosynthetic rate. Here we develop a new model of photoinhibition that captures this plateau. We test six new models of photoinhibition and ten more photoinhibition models from the literature against a database of 1808 photosynthesis-irradiance curves exhibiting photoinhibition. In the best model, photoinhibition is phenomenologically described by multiplication by a saturating function of the reciprocal of irradiance, simplifies to the widely-used Jassby & Platt photosynthesis-irradiance curve in the absence of photoinhibition, and only requires one new parameter. This photoinhibition parameter identifies the onset of photoinhibition and is the rate of decrease in photosynthetic rate at that irradiance. The parameters common to both of these models have a consistent interpretation, but our analysis of 3,615 experiments and 10,000 simulated datasets revealed significant discrepancies in parameter interpretation across other widely-used photoinhibition models. Deviations in parameter estimates across models of up to 40% were observed underscoring the need for consistent modeling approaches and supporting the application of our new photoinhibition model.

Other Quantitative Biology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is the deficiencies of existing photosynthesis - irradiance (PI) models in describing the photoinhibition phenomenon of phytoplankton. Specifically:

1. **Modeling of the photoinhibition phenomenon**: Most existing PI models overlook an important feature in the photoinhibition phenomenon - the photosynthetic rate remains at a constant maximum within a certain irradiance range until photoinhibition causes the photosynthetic rate to decline. This phenomenon is known as the "plateau", and existing models are unable to accurately capture this feature.

2. **Parameter estimation bias problem**: Since existing models cannot accurately describe the photoinhibition phenomenon, especially the decline in photosynthetic rate under high - irradiance conditions, this will lead to parameter estimation bias, which in turn affects the prediction accuracy of primary productivity and ecosystem models.

To solve these problems, the author proposes a new photoinhibition parameterization model, which can better describe the plateau in the photoinhibition phenomenon and simplifies to the commonly used Jassby & Platt photosynthesis - irradiance curve model in the absence of photoinhibition. The new model only adds a new parameter (the photoinhibition parameter β), making the model more concise and easier to interpret.

### Key features of the new model:
- **Plateau description**: The new model describes the plateau of the photosynthetic rate under high irradiance by introducing a saturation function, ensuring that the model can capture the phenomenon that the photosynthetic rate remains constant within a certain irradiance range.
- **Parameter consistency**: In the absence of photoinhibition, the new model can be simplified to the commonly used photosynthesis - irradiance model, ensuring the consistency of parameter interpretation and avoiding differences in parameter interpretation between different models.
- **Simplicity and interpretability**: The new model only adds one parameter, keeping the model simple while providing a clear explanation of the photoinhibition phenomenon.

### Experimental verification:
The author verified this new model using a data set containing 1,808 photosynthesis - irradiance curves and compared it with existing models. The results show that the new model performs excellently in describing the photoinhibition phenomenon, especially having a clear advantage in capturing the plateau.

In conclusion, this paper aims to improve the deficiencies of existing models in describing the photosynthesis - irradiance relationship of phytoplankton by proposing a new photoinhibition model, thereby improving the accuracy of predictions of primary productivity and ecosystem models.