Efficient Motion Sickness Assessment: Recreation of On-Road Driving on a Compact Test Track

Huseyin Harmankaya,Adrian Brietzke,Rebecca Pham Xuan,Barys Shyrokau,Riender Happee,Georgios Papaioannou
2024-12-19
Abstract:The ability to engage in other activities during the ride is considered by consumers as one of the key reasons for the adoption of automated vehicles. However, engagement in non-driving activities will provoke occupants' motion sickness, deteriorating their overall comfort and thereby risking acceptance of automated driving. Therefore, it is critical to extend our understanding of motion sickness and unravel the modulating factors that affect it through experiments with participants. Currently, most experiments are conducted on public roads (realistic but not reproducible) or test tracks (feasible with prototype automated vehicles). This research study develops a method to design an optimal path and speed reference to efficiently replicate on-road motion sickness exposure on a small test track. The method uses model predictive control to replicate the longitudinal and lateral accelerations collected from on-road drives on a test track of 70 m by 175 m. A within-subject experiment (47 participants) was conducted comparing the occupants' motion sickness occurrence in test-track and on-road conditions, with the conditions being cross-randomized. The results illustrate no difference and no effect of the condition on the occurrence of the average motion sickness across the participants. Meanwhile, there is an overall correspondence of individual sickness levels between on-road and test-track. This paves the path for the employment of our method for a simpler, safer and more replicable assessment of motion sickness.
Robotics,Emerging Technologies,Human-Computer Interaction
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### What problem does this paper attempt to solve? This paper aims to solve the problem of motion sickness (MS) that passengers may experience during non - driving activities in autonomous vehicles (AVs). Specifically, the main goal of the research is to develop a method that can efficiently reproduce the exposure to motion sickness when driving on the road on a small - scale test track. Through this method, researchers hope to evaluate and understand the occurrence of motion sickness and its influencing factors in a simpler, safer and more reproducible environment. #### Background and Problem Description 1. **Application Prospects of Autonomous Vehicles** - The development of autonomous vehicles is expected to change the way passengers use their commuting time. Surveys show that users expect to perform non - driving - related tasks (NDRTs) in autonomous vehicles, such as reading, working or entertainment. 2. **The Impact of Motion Sickness** - Research shows that 60 - 70% of the population may be affected by motion sickness in autonomous vehicles, especially in situations such as limited vision and rear - facing seats. - Motion sickness will reduce the overall comfort of passengers, thereby affecting the acceptance of autonomous driving technology. 3. **Limitations of Existing Experimental Methods** - **Public Road Experiments**: Although realistic, they are not reproducible and have safety hazards. - **Large - scale Test Tracks**: They are costly and difficult to fully simulate the complex real - driving environment. #### Research Objectives To solve the above problems, this study proposes an innovative method to reproduce the exposure to motion sickness on the road on a small - scale test track through model predictive control (MPC). Specific objectives include: 1. **Develop a Path - Planning Algorithm** - Use MPC to optimize the path and speed of the vehicle on the test track to replicate the longitudinal and lateral accelerations on the real road. 2. **Verify the Effectiveness of the Method** - Evaluate the effectiveness and reliability of the proposed method by comparing the occurrence of motion sickness among 47 participants on public roads and test tracks. 3. **Simplify the Evaluation Process** - Provide a simpler, safer and more reproducible method for evaluating motion sickness, thereby promoting the design and improvement of autonomous vehicles. #### Method Overview 1. **Data Collection** - Collect natural driving data on public roads and record longitudinal and lateral accelerations. 2. **Path Planning** - Use the MPC algorithm to design a path suitable for a small - scale test track, ensuring that the vehicle movement complies with the constraints of the test track. 3. **Experimental Design** - Through a cross - randomized experimental design, compare the occurrence of motion sickness among participants on public roads and test tracks to ensure the objectivity and reliability of the experimental results. 4. **Evaluation Indicators** - Use the objective evaluation indicators in the ISO - 2631:1997 standard, combined with subjective scores (such as the MISC scale), to comprehensively evaluate the occurrence of motion sickness. Through these steps, the research team hopes to provide valuable references for the future design of autonomous vehicles, ensuring that passengers can have a better experience during non - driving activities.