Abstract:Understanding coupled electron-phonon systems is one of the fundamental issues in strongly correlated systems. In this work, we aim to extend the notion of mixed-state phases to the realm of coupled electron/spinphonon systems. Specifically, we consider a two-dimensional cluster Hamiltonian locally coupled to a set of single bosonic modes with arbitrary coupling strength. First, we adopt a pure-state framework and examine whether a ground state phase transition out of the symmetry-protected topological phase can be captured using the standard polaron unitary transformation. This approach involves restricting the analysis to the low-energy manifold of the phonon degrees of freedom. We find that the pure-state approach fails to detect the anticipated transition to a topologically trivial phase at strong spin-phonon coupling. Next, we turn to a mixed-state picture. Here, we analyze mixed states of the model obtained by tracing out the phonons degrees of freedom. We employ two distinct diagnostics for mixed-state phase transitions: (i) the von Neumann conditional mutual information (CMI) and (ii) the Rényi-2 CMI. We argue that both measures detect signatures of mixed-state phase transitions, albeit at different critical spin-phonon coupling strengths, corresponding to subtly distinct notions of the mixed-state phases.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The core problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **How to understand and describe the mixed - state phase transitions in the coupled electron/spin - phonon systems**. Specifically, the authors explored whether the traditional pure - state framework (i.e., through the polaron transformation) can be used to capture the transition from the symmetry - protected topological (SPT) phase to the trivial phase under the condition of strong spin - phonon coupling. They found that the traditional pure - state method cannot detect the expected phase transition, so they turned to the mixed - state framework and introduced two different diagnostic tools - von Neumann conditional mutual information (CMI) and Rényi - 2 conditional mutual information (CMI) to detect the mixed - state phase transitions.
### Detailed Interpretation
1. **Research Background and Motivation**
- **Electron/Spin - Phonon Coupling** is one of the most fundamental interactions in quantum matter, which affects the phase diagrams of many - body systems.
- **Traditional Methods** usually decouple the entangled electron/spin - phonon states through the polaron transformation and then limit the analysis to the low - energy states. This method is applicable to the pure - state framework but may fail in the case of strong coupling.
- **The Mixed - State Framework** takes into account the influence of the environment (such as phonon modes) on the system and can more realistically describe the phase transitions in actual systems.
2. **Main Problems**
- **Limitations of the Pure - State Method**: Under strong spin - phonon coupling, the pure - state method cannot detect the transition from the SPT phase to the trivial phase.
- **Detection of Mixed - State Phase Transitions**: Two new diagnostic tools - von Neumann CMI and Rényi - 2 CMI are introduced to detect the mixed - state phase transitions.
3. **Specific Models and Methods**
- **Model**: A cluster - state model on a two - dimensional Lieb lattice is considered, with each lattice site locally coupled to the harmonic oscillator mode.
- **Pure - State Method**: The spins and phonons are decoupled through the polaron transformation and then projected onto the low - energy states. The results show that regardless of the coupling strength, the system always remains in the SPT phase, which is contrary to physical intuition.
- **Mixed - State Method**: By tracing out the phonon degrees of freedom, a "phonon - decohered" mixed - state density matrix is obtained. Analyzing this mixed state using von Neumann CMI and Rényi - 2 CMI, it is found that there is a critical coupling strength, and when the strength exceeds this value, the system undergoes a phase transition.
4. **Conclusions**
- **Failure of the Pure - State Method**: In the case of strong coupling, the pure - state method cannot capture the expected phase transition.
- **Success of the Mixed - State Method**: By introducing von Neumann CMI and Rényi - 2 CMI, the mixed - state phase transitions are successfully detected, and different types of CMI show phase - transition signals at different critical coupling strengths.
### Formula Summary
- **Von Neumann CMI**
\[
I_{vN}(A:C|B)=[S(AB) - S(B)] - [S(ABC) - S(BC)]
\]
where \( S(M) \) is the von Neumann entropy of region \( M \).
- **Rényi - 2 CMI**
\[
I_2(A:C|B)=[S^{(2)}(AB) - S^{(2)}(B)] - [S^{(2)}(ABC) - S^{(2)}(BC)]
\]
where \( S^{(2)}(M)=-\ln[\text{Tr}(\hat{\rho}_M^2)] \) is the Rényi - 2 entropy of region \( M \).
- **Bit - Flip Rate \( p \)**
\[
p=\frac{1}{2}\left[1 - e^{-2(g /\omega)^2}\right]
\]
Through these formulas, the authors show how to detect and understand complex phase - transition phenomena in the mixed - state framework.