Vibrational excitations in magnetic triangular nanographenes

Nils Krane,Elia Turco,Annika Bernhardt,Michal Juríček,Roman Fasel,Pascal Ruffieux

2024-11-29

Abstract:Inelastic electron tunneling spectroscopy (IETS) is a powerful measurement technique often used in scanning tunneling spectroscopy to probe excited states of various nanostructures, e.g., the magnetic properties of complex spin systems. The observed excited states can be of magnetic and vibrational origin and it is therefore necessary to differentiate between these two excitation mechanisms. Here, we investigate the spin S = 1/2 phenalenyl radical on Au(111). IETS measurements feature inelastic excitations, whereas the spatial distribution of their intensity excludes any spin excitations. Comparison to theoretical simulations proves the vibrational origin of those excitations and allows us to assign the observed features to distinct vibrational modes.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to distinguish the contributions of magnetic excitation and vibrational excitation in inelastic electron tunneling spectroscopy (IETS) measurements. Specifically, the research focuses on how to identify and confirm the sources of vibrational excitation through experimental and theoretical simulation methods.

### Research Background
- **Research Object**: The paper mainly studies the smallest member of the triangular nanographene family - the phenalenyl radical, which has the property of spin \( S=\frac{1}{2} \).
- **Technical Means**: Use scanning tunneling microscopy (STM) and inelastic electron tunneling spectroscopy (IETS) for measurement to detect the excited states of molecules.
- **Core of the Problem**: Since IETS measurement can detect magnetic and vibrational excitations, it is necessary to distinguish these two different excitation mechanisms. Especially when studying complex spin systems, it is crucial to correctly identify these excitation mechanisms.

### Solutions
1. **Experimental Methods**:
- By performing STM and IETS measurements on the Au(111) surface, obtain dI/dV spectra at different positions.
- By comparing the Kondo resonance intensity at different positions and the distribution of IETS steps, it is found that the Kondo resonance is the strongest at the molecular edge, while the IETS steps are concentrated in the molecular center.
2. **Theoretical Simulation**:
- Use density functional theory (DFT) calculations to simulate the vibrational modes of the phenalenyl radical and their influence on the tunneling probability.
- By comparing the experimental results with the theoretical simulation, it is confirmed that the observed IETS steps originate from specific vibrational modes rather than magnetic excitation.
3. **Verification Process**:
- Experimentally, draw constant - height dI/dV maps at different bias voltages, and obtain the spatial distribution corresponding to the IETS steps through numerical processing.
- Compare the experimental results with the theoretical simulation of the spatial distribution, and the two are highly consistent, further proving the origin of vibrational excitation.

### Conclusions
Through the combination of experimental and theoretical methods, the authors successfully identified and confirmed the vibrational excitation of the phenalenyl radical on the Au(111) surface. This result helps to better understand the inelastic tunneling mechanism and provides an important reference for future research on the magnetic and vibrational properties of nanographene.

### Formula Display
The formulas involved in the paper include:

- The root - mean - square expression of vibrational displacement:
\[
\delta Q_k=\sqrt{\frac{\hbar}{2\omega_k}}
\]

- The calculation formula of the tunneling matrix element:
\[
|M_k|^2=\left|\frac{\hbar^2}{2m_e Z}\int_{\vec{S}}d\vec{S}\cdot\left(\Psi_s\nabla\delta\Psi_{m,k}-\delta\Psi_{m,k}\nabla\Psi_s\right)\right|^2
\]
where \( \Psi_s \) is the s - wave function of the tip, and \( \delta\Psi_{m,k} \) is the change in the molecular orbital wave function after being perturbed by the vibrational mode k.

Through these methods, researchers can accurately distinguish and confirm the sources of vibrational excitation, thus solving the problem that magnetic excitation and vibrational excitation are difficult to distinguish in IETS measurements.