Probing local moments in nanographenes with electron tunneling spectroscopy

Ricardo Ortiz,Joaquín Fernández-Rossier
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.progsurf.2020.100595
2020-02-19
Abstract:The emergence of local moments in graphene zigzag edges, grain boundaries, vacancies and sp3 defects has been widely studied theoretically. However, conclusive experimental evidence is scarce. Recent progress in on-surface synthesis has made it possible to create nanographenes, such as triangulenes, with local moments in their ground states, and to probe them using scanning tunnelling microscope (STM) spectroscopy. Here we review the application of the theory of sequential and cotunneling transport to relate the dI/dV spectra with the spin properties of nanographenes probed by STM. This approach permits us to connect the dI/dV with the many-body energies and wavefunctions of the graphene nanostructures. We apply this method describing the electronic states of the nanographenes by means of exact diagonalization of the Hubbard model within a restricted Active Space. This permits us to provide a proper quantum description of the emergence of local moments in graphene and its interplay with transport. We discuss the results of this theory in the case of diradical nanographenes, such as triangulene, rectangular ribbons and the Clar goblet, that have been recently studied experimentally by means of STM spectroscopy. This approach permits us to calculate both the dI/dV spectra, that yields excitation energies, as well as the atomically resolved conductivity maps, that provide information on the wavefunctions of the collective spin modes.
Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is related to the detection and understanding of local magnetic moments in graphene nanostructures. Specifically, the research aims to explore the characteristics of local magnetic moments in nanographene with specific edge structures (such as zig - zag edges) through electron tunneling spectroscopy. The following is a detailed explanation of this problem: ### Research Background and Problem Description 1. **Theoretical Prediction and Experimental Verification** - Theoretically, graphene and its nanostructures can generate local magnetic moments under certain conditions (such as zig - zag edges, grain boundaries, vacancies, and sp3 defects). These magnetic moments mainly originate from unpaired electrons in the π orbit. - However, experimentally, there is relatively little evidence for directly detecting these local magnetic moments, especially for the nanographene system. 2. **Experimental Progress** - Recent advances in surface synthesis techniques have enabled researchers to create nanographene structures with local magnetic moments (such as triangulene) and detect them by scanning tunneling microscopy (STM). - For example, STM spectroscopy can provide dI/dV spectra, which can reflect the spin characteristics of the system. 3. **Research Objectives** - The goal of this paper is to theoretically relate the dI/dV spectra to the spin properties of nanographene, thereby better understanding the formation mechanisms of these local magnetic moments and their relationships with transport properties. - Specifically, the authors applied the sequential tunneling and inelastic cotunneling transport theories, combined with the exact diagonalization of the Hubbard model, to calculate the dI/dV spectra and atom - resolved conductance maps. ### Key Formulas and Methods 1. **Energy Conservation Condition** \[ \mu_T+E_G(N) = E_G(N + 1) \] where \(\mu_T\) is the Fermi level of the tip, and \(E_G(N)\) is the energy of nanographene containing \(N\) electrons. 2. **Relationship between Bias Voltage and Chemical Potential** \[ \mu_T=\mu_S+|e|V_{\text{bias}} \] where \(\mu_S\) is the chemical potential of the substrate, and \(V_{\text{bias}}\) is the bias voltage. 3. **Energy Difference in the Sequential Tunneling Process** \[ E^+ = |e|V^+ = E_G(N + 1)-E_G(N)-\mu_S \] \[ E^- = |e|V^- = E_G(N - 1)-E_G(N)+\mu_S \] 4. **Inelastic Cotunneling Condition** \[ |eV_{\text{cot}}|\geq\Delta \] where \(\Delta\) is the energy difference between two many - body states. 5. **Hamiltonian** \[ H_{\text{NG}} = H_{\text{Hub}}+H_C+H_{\text{Zee}}+H_\lambda+H_{\text{def}} \] where \(H_{\text{Hub}}\) is the Hubbard model, \(H_C\) and \(H_{\text{Zee}}\) are the on - site energy of carbon atoms and the Zeeman coupling term respectively, \(H_\lambda\) is an additional charging energy term, and \(H_{\text{def}}\) is the deformation term caused by the STM tip. ### Conclusion Through the above theories and methods, the authors successfully explained the dI/dV spectra observed in the experiment and provided a quantum description of the formation of local magnetic moments in nanographene. This not only deepens the understanding of these complex systems but also provides a theoretical basis and experimental guidance for future research.