Influence of the Dirac Sea on Phase Transitions in Monolayer Graphene under Strong Magnetic Fields

Guopeng Xu,Chunli Huang

2024-11-26

Abstract:Recent scanning tunneling microscopy experiments have found Kekulé-Distorted (KD) ordering in graphene subjected to strong magnetic fields, a departure from the antiferromagnetic (AF) state identified in earlier transport experiments on double-encapsulated devices with larger dielectric screening constant $\epsilon$. This variation suggests that the magnetic anisotropic energy is sensitive to dielectric screening constant. To calculate the magnetic anisotropic energy without resorting to perturbation theory, we adopted a two-step approach. First, we derived the bare valley-sublattice dependent interaction coupling constants from microscopic calculations and account for the leading logarithmic divergences arising from quantum fluctuations by solving renormalization group flow equations in the absence of magnetic field from the carbon lattice scale up to the much larger magnetic length. Subsequently, we used these renormalized coupling constants to perform non-perturbative, self-consistent Hartree-Fock calculations. Our results demonstrate that the ground state at neutrality ($\nu=0$) transitions from a AF state to a spin-singlet KD state when dielectric screening and magnetic fields become small, consistent with experimental observations. For filling fraction $\nu=\pm1$, we predict a transitions from spin-polarized charge-density wave states to spin-polarized KD state when dielectric screening and magnetic fields become small. Our self-consistent Hartree-Fock calculations, which encompass a large number of Landau levels, reveal that the magnetic anisotropic energy receives substantial contributions from the Dirac sea when $\epsilon$ is small. Our work provides insights into how the Dirac sea, which contributes to one electron per graphene unit cell, affects the small magnetic anisotropic energy in graphene.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Strongly Correlated Electrons

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the paper attempts to solve

This paper aims to explore the influence of the Dirac sea in monolayer graphene on phase transitions under a strong magnetic field. Specifically, the researchers focused on the following aspects:

1. **Transformation between Kekulé distortion (KD) order and antiferromagnetic (AF) order**:
- Recent scanning tunneling microscope experiments have found that under the action of a strong magnetic field, graphene exhibits Kekulé distortion (KD) order, which is different from the antiferromagnetic (AF) order observed in earlier transport experiments. This difference indicates that the magnetic anisotropy energy is sensitive to the dielectric screening constant.
- The researchers adopted a two - step method to calculate the magnetic anisotropy energy. First, they derived the bare valley - sublattice - dependent interaction coupling constants from microscopic calculations and considered the logarithmic divergence caused by quantum fluctuations by solving the renormalization group flow equations. Subsequently, they used these renormalized coupling constants for non - perturbative self - consistent Hartree - Fock calculations.
- The results show that at the neutral point (ν = 0), when the dielectric screening and the magnetic field are weak, the ground state transforms from the antiferromagnetic (AF) state to the spin - singlet Kekulé distortion (KD) state, which is consistent with experimental observations.

2. **Phase transitions at filling fraction ν = ±1**:
- For the filling fraction ν = ±1, the researchers predicted that when the dielectric screening and the magnetic field are weak, the system will transform from the spin - polarized charge - density - wave (CDW) state to the spin - polarized Kekulé distortion (KD) state.
- Self - consistent Hartree - Fock calculations show that when the dielectric screening constant is small, the magnetic anisotropy energy obtains a significant contribution from the Dirac sea.

3. **The influence of the Dirac sea on the magnetic anisotropy energy**:
- Through self - consistent Hartree - Fock calculations including a large number of Landau levels, the researchers revealed the important contribution of the Dirac sea to the magnetic anisotropy energy.
- These results provide insights into how the Dirac sea affects the small magnetic anisotropy energy in graphene.

### Summary

This paper systematically studied the influence of the Dirac sea in monolayer graphene on phase transitions under a strong magnetic field by combining the renormalization group technique and the self - consistent Hartree - Fock theory. The research results not only explain the experimentally observed Kekulé distortion order but also predict the phase - transition behaviors at different filling fractions, providing a new perspective for understanding the quantum Hall states in graphene.