Landau-Level Mixing and SU(4) Symmetry Breaking in Graphene

Nemin Wei,Guopeng Xu,Inti Sodemann Villadiego,Chunli Huang

2024-01-23

Abstract:Recent scanning tunneling microscopy experiments on graphene at charge neutrality under strong magnetic fields have uncovered a ground state characterized by Kekulé distortion (KD). In contrast, non-local spin and charge transport experiments in double-encapsulated graphene, which has a higher dielectric constant, have identified an antiferromagnetic (AF) ground state. We propose a mechanism to reconcile these conflicting observations, by showing that Landau-level mixing can drive a transition from AF to KD with the reduction of the dielectric screening. Our conclusion is drawn from studying the effect of Landau-level mixing on the lattice-scale, valley-dependent interactions to leading order in graphene's fine structure constant $\kappa = e^2/(\hbar v_F \epsilon)$. This analysis provides three key insights: 1) Valley-dependent interactions remain predominantly short-range with the $m=0$ Haldane pseudopotential being at least an order of magnitude greater than the others, affirming the validity of delta-function approximation for these interactions. 2) The phase transition between the AF and KD states is driven by the microscopic process in the double-exchange Feynman diagram. 3) The magnitudes of the coupling constants are significantly boosted by remote Landau levels. Our model also provides a theoretical basis for numerical studies of fractional quantum Hall states in graphene.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics,Strongly Correlated Electrons

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the inconsistency of different experimentally - observed ground states near the electrical neutral point in graphene under a strong magnetic field. Specifically:

1. **Scanning Tunneling Microscopy (STM) Experiment**: Under a strong magnetic field, the STM experiment discovered the Kekulé Distortion (KD) state.
2. **Non - local Spin and Charge Transport Experiments**: These experiments discovered an antiferromagnetic (AF) ground state in double - encapsulated graphene (with a relatively high dielectric constant).

These two experimental results are contradictory because they respectively support different ground states. To reconcile these conflicting observations, the authors proposed a mechanism, that is, by studying the influence of Landau level mixing on lattice - scale, valley - dependent interactions, to explain the transition from AF to KD.

### Main Problems:
- **How to explain the different ground states observed under different experimental conditions?**
- **How does Landau level mixing affect the transitions between these ground states?**

### Solutions:
The authors solve this problem through the following methods:
1. **Introduce the fine - structure constant \(\kappa=\frac{e^{2}}{\hbar v_{F}\epsilon}\)**, which controls the strength of the SU(4) - symmetric long - range Coulomb interaction and the degree of Landau level mixing.
2. **Analyze the influence of Landau level mixing on valley - dependent interactions**, especially by calculating the correction terms in Feynman diagrams to quantify these influences.
3. **Reveal that as \(\kappa\) increases**, \(u_{\perp}(\kappa)\) decreases faster than \(u_{z}(\kappa)\) increases, thus leading to the phase transition from AF to KD.

### Key Conclusions:
- **As the dielectric constant \(\epsilon\) decreases** (that is, \(\kappa\) increases), the system transitions from the AF ground state to the KD ground state.
- **This transition is driven by the double - exchange Feynman diagram**, which can transform the repulsive valley - exchange scattering \(g_{\perp\perp}\) into an attractive \(u_{\perp}\).
- **The long - range Landau levels significantly enhance the magnitude of the coupling constants**, making these interactions 3 to 5 times stronger than the Zeeman energy.

Through these analyses, the authors provide a theoretical framework that explains the different ground states observed under different experimental conditions and lays the foundation for further research on fractional quantum Hall states in graphene.