F. S. Ricci,C. K. Ukegbu,A. Krassner,S. Hazarika,J. White,M. Porfiri,J.R. Rizzo
Abstract:This study explores the use of virtual reality (VR) as an innovative tool to enhance awareness, acceptance, and understanding of accessibility for persons with vision loss (VL). Through a VR-based workshop developed in collaboration with New York City's Department Of Transportation, participants experienced immersive simulations of VL and and related immersive mobility challenges. The methodology included pre- and post-intervention questionnaires, assessing changes in participants' knowledge, confidence, and perception. Participants included urban planners, designers, and architects. Results showed a significant increase in awareness of VL-related challenges that affect design guidelines, as well as improved confidence in addressing such challenges. Participants also expressed strong support for VR as a pedagogical tool, noting its potential for reshaping professional practices, improving capacity building, and enhancing inclusive design. The study demonstrates the effectiveness of VR as an experiential learning platform, fostering empathy and a long-term commitment to integrating VL considerations into urban design. These findings highlight the transformative potential of VR in advancing equity and accessibility in urban environments.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: How to enhance the mobility, safety, and fairness of the visually impaired in the urban environment through virtual reality (VR) technology. Specifically, the research aims to promote more inclusive urban design by increasing participants' awareness, acceptance, and understanding of the challenges faced by the visually impaired in the urban environment through a VR - based workshop.
### Background of the Paper and Problem Description
The urban environment is full of diverse spaces and paths, and for the visually impaired, these spaces bring many challenges that are not noticed by people with normal vision. For example, uneven sidewalks, poorly - maintained footpaths, parked vehicles, or street furniture may all impede their movement and pose safety hazards. In addition, stairs and curbs are also significant obstacles, and the visually impaired need to find alternative routes or seek help to pass. These physical obstacles not only affect the physical movement of the visually impaired but may also have a negative impact on their emotional well - being, such as anxiety, frustration, and insecurity.
### Research Methods
To improve the accessibility and inclusiveness of the urban environment, the research team organized a workshop named InSight, with participants including members of the New York City Department of Transportation (DOT). The workshop simulated different visual impairment situations through virtual reality technology and let participants experience the challenges of navigating in a complex urban environment. The research methods include:
1. **Virtual Reality Design**: Used Unity software to create an immersive virtual urban environment, simulating the actual scenes in New York City, including various obstacles and risk factors.
2. **Visual Impairment Simulation**: Through shader effects and culling mask techniques, simulated three of the most common types of visual impairment: age - related macular degeneration (AMD), diabetic retinopathy (DR), and glaucoma, each divided into three stages: mild, moderate, and severe.
3. **Workshop Implementation**: Conducted the workshop at the Tandon School of Engineering, New York University. Participants used VR headsets and controllers to navigate in the virtual environment, trying to avoid obstacles and complete tasks.
4. **Questionnaire Surveys and Focus Group Discussions**: Evaluated the changes in participants' knowledge, confidence, and attitudes through pre - and post - intervention questionnaires, and collected more detailed feedback through focus group discussions.
### Main Findings
1. **Enhancement of Knowledge and Awareness**: VR intervention significantly improved participants' understanding of terms related to visual impairment and their awareness of urban design guidelines. For example, before the intervention, only 10% of participants had high confidence in "blind" and "low vision", and after the intervention, this proportion increased to 65%.
2. **Increase in Confidence**: Participants showed higher confidence when discussing the mobility issues of the visually impaired. Before the intervention, less than 20% of participants were confident in this regard, and after the intervention, this proportion increased to nearly 70%.
3. **Enhanced Willingness to Apply**: More than 80% of participants indicated that they would consider the needs of the visually impaired in future designs, while before the intervention, this proportion was only 40%.
### Conclusion
This research demonstrates the effectiveness of virtual reality in increasing participants' awareness, acceptance, and understanding of the needs of the visually impaired. Through this immersive learning platform, participants can better understand the challenges faced by the visually impaired in the urban environment, thereby promoting more inclusive and accessible urban design. These findings emphasize the great potential of VR technology in promoting fairness and accessibility in the urban environment.