Near-Range Environmental Perception for Inland Waterway Vessels: A Comparative Study of LiDAR and Automotive FMCW RADAR Sensors

R. Herrmann,S. Bose,I. Filip,D. Medina,R. Ziebold,S. Gehrig,T. Lenhard,M. Gardill
2024-11-25
Abstract:Advancing towards high automation and autonomous operations is crucial for the future of inland waterway transport (IWT) systems. These systems necessitate robust and precise onboard sensory technologies that can perceive the environment under all weather conditions, including static features for local positioning techniques such as Simultaneous Localization and Mapping (SLAM). Traditional marine RADAR, mandatory on vessels and operating in the 9300-9500 MHz frequency band, can cover ranges from 15 to 1200 meters but are inadequate for detecting closer objects, making them unsuitable for automated docking maneuvers, lock entry, or bridge undercrossings. This necessitates the development of reliable close-range sensor technology that functions effectively in all weather conditions. In present research works on vessel automation, LiDAR sensors, operating in the nearinfrared range, are used predominantly to detect the immediate surroundings of vessels but suffer significant degradation in poor visibility. Conversely, automotive RADAR sensors, utilizing the 76-81 GHz frequency band, can detect objects from a few centimeters to up to 200 meters, even in adverse conditions. These sensors are commonly used in advanced autonomous road traffic systems and are evaluated in this study for their suitability in inland navigation and maneuvering. This paper discusses a distributed sensor network of four compact automotive frequencymodulated continuous-wave (FMCW) radars mounted on a cabin boat as a test platform. Initial field experiments demonstrate the RADAR network's ability to perceive closerange static environmental features around the boat in inland waters. The paper also provides a comparative analysis of the environmental detection capabilities of automotive RADAR and LiDAR sensors.
Signal Processing
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: How to provide reliable short - range environmental perception technologies for inland waterway ships to support the requirements of high - automation and autonomous operations. Specifically, the paper focuses on how to effectively detect static features around the ship (such as SLAM for local positioning technologies) under various weather conditions, especially in bad weather conditions, and how to achieve complex operations such as automatic berthing, passing through locks and passing under bridges. ### Problem Background 1. **Automation Requirements of Inland Waterway Transport Systems** - The future development of the inland waterway transport system (IWT) requires high - automation and autonomous operations. - Automation and autonomous operations require accurate and reliable sensor technologies to perceive the surrounding environment, especially in complex environments such as narrow waterways, under bridges and in locks. 2. **Limitations of Existing Technologies** - **Traditional Marine Radars**: Although they have a wide coverage range (15 to 1200 meters), their ability to detect close - range objects is insufficient and cannot meet the requirements of operations such as automatic berthing. - **LiDAR Sensors**: Although they can detect close - range objects in detail, their performance drops significantly in bad weather conditions (such as heavy rain, thick fog or heavy snow). - **Automotive FMCW Radars**: They have good close - range detection capabilities (a few centimeters to 200 meters) and can work normally in bad weather conditions, but their resolution is low. ### Research Objectives - **Develop Reliable Short - Range Sensor Technologies**: The research aims to develop a short - range sensor technology that can work effectively under various weather conditions, especially suitable for autonomous driving and maneuvering in inland waterways. - **Evaluate the Applicability of Automotive FMCW Radars**: By comparing automotive FMCW radars with LiDAR sensors, evaluate their applicability and performance in the inland waterway environment. ### Solutions - **Distributed Sensor Network**: The paper proposes a distributed sensor network composed of four compact automotive frequency - modulated continuous - wave (FMCW) radars and installs it on a test platform (such as the Aurora ship cabin). - **Experimental Verification**: Through field experiments in Berlin and Neustrelitz, the performance of LiDAR and FMCW radars in different environments, including urban and natural environments, is compared. - **Data Analysis**: Quantitative indicators such as point - cloud density and Jaccard coefficient are used to evaluate the performance differences between the two sensors. ### Conclusions Although the point - cloud density of automotive FMCW radars is low, their perception ability in the inland waterway environment shows great potential. Future research will focus on improving time synchronization, increasing target positioning accuracy, more precisely measuring the position of radar sensors, and exploring positioning and mapping algorithms suitable for radar point clouds. In addition, radar waveform optimization adapted to the surrounding environment, that is, cognitive radar, will also be studied. ### Formula Summary 1. **Average Cell Count** \[ N_{1m^2}=\frac{1}{M - K}\sum_{m = 0}^{M}N_m \] where \(K\) is the number of cells where \(N_m = 0\). 2. **Jaccard Coefficient** \[ J(A,B)=\frac{|A\cap B|}{|A\cup B|}, \quad 0\leq J\leq1 \] These formulas are used to quantify the density and similarity of LiDAR and FMCW radar point clouds.