Assessing the Robustness of LiDAR, Radar and Depth Cameras Against Ill-Reflecting Surfaces in Autonomous Vehicles: An Experimental Study

Michael Loetscher,Nicolas Baumann,Edoardo Ghignone,Andrea Ronco,Michele Magno
2023-09-19
Abstract:Range-measuring sensors play a critical role in autonomous driving systems. While LiDAR technology has been dominant, its vulnerability to adverse weather conditions is well-documented. This paper focuses on secondary adverse conditions and the implications of ill-reflective surfaces on range measurement sensors. We assess the influence of this condition on the three primary ranging modalities used in autonomous mobile robotics: LiDAR, RADAR, and Depth-Camera. Based on accurate experimental evaluation the papers findings reveal that under ill-reflectivity, LiDAR ranging performance drops significantly to 33% of its nominal operating conditions, whereas RADAR and Depth-Cameras maintain up to 100% of their nominal distance ranging capabilities. Additionally, we demonstrate on a 1:10 scaled autonomous racecar how ill-reflectivity adversely impacts downstream robotics tasks, highlighting the necessity for robust range sensing in autonomous driving.
Robotics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the performance degradation of range - measuring sensors (such as LiDAR, RADAR, and depth cameras) in autonomous vehicles when facing poorly reflective surfaces. Specifically, the paper focuses on the robustness of these sensors when encountering low - reflectivity materials and how this performance degradation affects downstream robotic tasks, such as localization, planning, and control. Through experimental research, the authors evaluate the performance of different sensors under poor - reflection conditions and explore the impact of these results on autonomous driving technology. ### Summary of the core problems in the paper: 1. **Evaluate the performance of range - measuring sensors under poor - reflection conditions**: Research the measurement accuracy of LiDAR, RADAR, and depth cameras when encountering low - reflectivity materials. 2. **Analyze the impact of poor reflection on downstream robotic tasks**: Through 1:10 - scale autonomous racing car experiments, evaluate the impact of poor - reflection conditions on localization, planning, and control tasks in autonomous driving systems. 3. **Propose improvement measures**: Based on the experimental results, explore how to improve the robustness and reliability of autonomous driving systems through multi - modal sensor fusion. ### Specific problem descriptions: - **Performance degradation of LiDAR**: Under poor - reflection conditions, the ranging performance of LiDAR drops significantly, only reaching 33% of that under normal conditions. - **Performance of RADAR and depth cameras**: RADAR and depth cameras can still maintain relatively high ranging performance under poor - reflection conditions, which are 100% and close to 100% respectively. - **Impact on downstream tasks**: Experimental results show that the ranging error under poor - reflection conditions will directly affect the localization accuracy and control performance of autonomous vehicles, thus affecting overall driving safety. Through the research of these problems, the paper aims to provide important references and improvement directions for the development of autonomous driving technology, especially in complex and diverse actual driving environments, how to ensure the robustness and reliability of sensors.