GPT versus Humans: Uncovering Ethical Concerns in Conversational Generative AI-empowered Multi-Robot Systems

Rebekah Rousi,Niko Makitalo,Hooman Samani,Kai-Kristian Kemell,Jose Siqueira de Cerqueira,Ville Vakkuri,Tommi Mikkonen,Pekka Abrahamsson
2024-11-21
Abstract:The emergence of generative artificial intelligence (GAI) and large language models (LLMs) such ChatGPT has enabled the realization of long-harbored desires in software and robotic development. The technology however, has brought with it novel ethical challenges. These challenges are compounded by the application of LLMs in other machine learning systems, such as multi-robot systems. The objectives of the study were to examine novel ethical issues arising from the application of LLMs in multi-robot systems. Unfolding ethical issues in GPT agent behavior (deliberation of ethical concerns) was observed, and GPT output was compared with human experts. The article also advances a model for ethical development of multi-robot systems. A qualitative workshop-based method was employed in three workshops for the collection of ethical concerns: two human expert workshops (N=16 participants) and one GPT-agent-based workshop (N=7 agents; two teams of 6 agents plus one judge). Thematic analysis was used to analyze the qualitative data. The results reveal differences between the human-produced and GPT-based ethical concerns. Human experts placed greater emphasis on new themes related to deviance, data privacy, bias and unethical corporate conduct. GPT agents emphasized concerns present in existing AI ethics guidelines. The study contributes to a growing body of knowledge in context-specific AI ethics and GPT application. It demonstrates the gap between human expert thinking and LLM output, while emphasizing new ethical concerns emerging in novel technology.
Robotics,Human-Computer Interaction,Multiagent Systems
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the new ethical issues that arise when applying large - language models (LLMs) such as GPT in multi - robot systems. Specifically, the research aims to explore the ethical challenges that these technologies may trigger in practical applications and reveal these differences by comparing the behaviors of human experts and GPT agents. The research also devotes itself to developing an ethical development model for multi - robot systems to guide future technology designs to be more in line with ethical standards. The paper collected ethical concerns through three workshops: two workshops with the participation of 16 human experts and one workshop with the participation of a team of 7 GPT agents (including two groups and one referee). Through thematic analysis of these data, the research found that human experts are more concerned about emerging topics related to deviant behavior, data privacy, prejudice, and unethical corporate behavior, while GPT agents place more emphasis on issues in existing AI ethical guidelines. This research not only reveals the gap between human expert thinking and the output of large - language models but also emphasizes the new ethical issues emerging in new technologies, contributing to the AI ethical knowledge system in specific situations.