Matroid Secretary via Labeling Schemes

Kristóf Bérczi,Vasilis Livanos,José Soto,Victor Verdugo

2024-11-19

Abstract:The Matroid Secretary Problem (MSP) is one of the most prominent settings for online resource allocation and optimal stopping. A decision-maker is presented with a ground set of elements $E$ revealed sequentially and in random order. Upon arrival, an irrevocable decision is made in a take-it-or-leave-it fashion, subject to a feasibility constraint on the set of selected elements captured by a matroid defined over $E$. The decision-maker only has ordinal access to compare the elements, and the goal is to design an algorithm that selects every element of the optimal basis with probability at least $\alpha$ (i.e., $\alpha$-probability-competitive). While the existence of a constant probability-competitive algorithm for MSP remains a major open question, simple greedy policies are at the core of state-of-the-art algorithms for several matroid classes. We introduce a flexible and general algorithmic framework to analyze greedy-like algorithms for MSP based on constructing a language associated with the matroid. Using this language, we establish a lower bound on the probability-competitiveness of the algorithm by studying a corresponding Poisson point process that governs the words' distribution in the language. Using our framework, we break the state-of-the-art guarantee for laminar matroids by settling the probability-competitiveness of the greedy-improving algorithm to be exactly $1-\ln(2) \approx 0.3068$. For graphic matroids, we show a probability-competitiveness of $0.2693$ when the underlying graph has no parallel edges and a guarantee of $0.2504$ for general graphs, also breaking the state-of-the-art factor of $0.25$.

Data Structures and Algorithms

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is an important problem in online resource allocation and optimal stopping theory - the Matroid Secretary Problem (MSP). Specifically, the MSP is set up as follows:

1. **Problem Background**:
- There is a set of elements \( E \), and these elements will appear one by one in a random order.
- Whenever an element arrives, the decision - maker must immediately decide whether to select this element, and once the choice is made, it cannot be revoked.
- The set of selected elements must satisfy the independence constraint defined by the matroid.

2. **Objective**:
- Design an algorithm such that for each element in the optimal basis, the probability that it is selected is at least \( \alpha \) (i.e., \( \alpha \)-probability competitiveness).
- The main objective of the paper is to improve the competitive ratio of existing algorithms, especially for certain types of matroids (such as laminar matroids and graphic matroids).

3. **Current Challenges**:
- For general matroids, whether there exists an algorithm with constant - probability competitiveness is still an open question.
- The simple greedy strategy performs well in some matroid classes, but its performance needs to be improved for a wider range of matroid classes.

4. **Paper Contributions**:
- A new algorithmic framework is introduced to analyze greedy - like algorithms by constructing a language associated with the matroid.
- Use the Poisson point process to study the distribution of "words" in the language, thereby establishing a lower bound on the probability competitiveness of the algorithm.
- For laminar matroids, it is proved that the exact probability competitiveness of the greedy - improved algorithm is \( 1-\ln(2)\approx0.3068 \), breaking the previous record.
- For graphic matroids, in the case of no parallel edges, the probability competitiveness reaches \( 0.2693 \), and for general graphs, it reaches \( 0.2504 \), also exceeding the previous best results.

In summary, this paper aims to enhance the understanding of the Matroid Secretary Problem by introducing a new analytical framework and provide better algorithmic guarantees for certain types of matroids.