A Classical Analogue of Entanglement for a Kicked Top

Bilal Khalid,Sabre Kais
2024-11-14
Abstract:The kicked top is one of the most extensively studied paradigms of quantum chaos. In this model, an intricate connection has been observed between entanglement entropy and classical dynamics. This connection appears surprising since both chaos and entanglement are understood to be exclusive to classical and quantum mechanics respectively. In this paper, we have argued that from an alternative standpoint on classical physics, this connection becomes completely natural. According to this view, classical states are more accurately represented by distributions instead of infinitely precise points in phase space. Many properties that have traditionally been held to be exclusively quantum, such as non-separability of states, appear in classical physics too in this picture. Looking at the kicked top from this paradigm of classical physics provides a completely fresh outlook to the chaos-entanglement discussion. This finding opens new avenues of understanding in quantum chaos and the more general problem of classical-quantum correspondence.
Quantum Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore the relationship between classical physics and quantum physics, especially the connection between chaos and entanglement. Specifically, by studying the "kicked top model", the author proposes a new classical physics paradigm to explain this connection. ### Core problems of the paper 1. **The correlation between classical chaos and quantum entanglement**: - Traditionally, chaos is regarded as a phenomenon in classical physics, while entanglement is a property unique to quantum physics. However, in some systems (such as the kicked top model), it is observed that when the initial conditions are in the classical chaotic region, the quantum entanglement entropy of the system is greater than when it is in the classical regular region. - This correlation is surprising because chaos and entanglement are usually considered to belong to the classical and quantum fields respectively and have no direct connection with each other. 2. **Non - separability in classical physics**: - The author proposes that by abandoning the infinite - precision assumption in classical physics (that is, physical quantities can be accurate to an infinite number of digits), classical states can be described by phase - space densities instead of infinitely precise points. - In this new paradigm, a non - separability property similar to quantum entanglement also appears in classical physics. For example, by defining the classical mutual information, this non - separability can be quantified. ### Specific methods and results - **Classical and quantum dynamics of the kicked top model**: - The paper describes in detail the classical dynamic equations of the kicked top model and shows the process in which the classical phase space gradually transitions from regular motion to chaotic motion as the kicking strength \(\kappa\) increases. - At the same time, the author calculates the von Neumann entanglement entropy of a single spin and compares it with classical fluctuations. - **Comparison between classical mutual information and quantum entanglement entropy**: - The author further calculates the classical mutual information \(I_{12}\) and compares it with the quantum entanglement entropy \(S\). The results show that the two exhibit significant similarities under different initial conditions, especially when transitioning from the regular region to the chaotic region, the change trends of the classical mutual information and the quantum entanglement entropy are the same. ### Conclusions and prospects By introducing the concept of classical non - separability, the author provides a new perspective for understanding the relationship between classical chaos and quantum entanglement. This finding not only helps to deepen the understanding of quantum chaos but also provides new ideas for further exploring the correspondence between classical and quantum physics. Future research can explore the classical - quantum correspondence of more complex systems on this basis and the potential of these relationships in practical applications. ### Formula summary - **Von Neumann entanglement entropy**: \[ S(n)=-\text{Tr}\{\rho_1(n)\ln\rho_1(n)\} \] where \(\rho_1(n)=\text{Tr}_{i\neq1}\{|\psi(t = n\tau)\rangle\langle\psi(t = n\tau)|\}\). - **Classical mutual information**: \[ I_{12}=\int X_1\int X_2\rho(X_1, X_2)\log\left(\frac{\rho(X_1, X_2)}{\rho_1(X_1)\rho_2(X_2)}\right)dX_1dX_2 \] - **Relative fluctuation**: \[ (\Delta J)^2/J^2=\langle X^2\rangle-\langle X\rangle^2 \] Through these formulas, the author shows the profound connection between classical physics and quantum physics, providing a theoretical basis for future interdisciplinary research.