Tabea Herrmann,Maximilian F. I. Kieler,Arnd Bäcker
Abstract:Quantum many-body systems are commonly considered as quantum chaotic if their spectral statistics, such as the level spacing distribution, agree with those of random matrix theory. Using the example of the kicked Ising chain we demonstrate that even if both level spacing distribution and eigenvector statistics agree well with random matrix predictions, the entanglement entropy deviates from the expected Page curve. To explain this observation we propose a new measure of the effective spin interactions and obtain the corresponding random matrix result. By this the deviations of the entanglement entropy can be attributed to significantly different behavior of the $k$-spin interactions compared with RMT.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: even if the energy - level spacing distribution of a quantum many - body system conforms to the prediction of random matrix theory (RMT), that is, it exhibits quantum - chaotic characteristics, its entanglement entropy may also not conform to the behavior predicted by RMT. Specifically, by studying the kicked Ising spin chain model, the paper shows that even when both the energy - level spacing distribution and the eigenvector statistics conform to RMT, the entanglement entropy may still deviate from the expected Page curve.
### Research Background
1. **Quantum Chaotic Systems**:
- A quantum many - body system is usually considered to be quantum - chaotic if its spectral statistics (such as energy - level spacing distribution) conform to the prediction of random matrix theory.
- For single - particle systems, the spectral statistics in the classical chaotic limit also follow the RMT prediction, and this relationship has been extended to many - body systems without a classical limit.
2. **RMT Predictions**:
- RMT was initially used to describe the spectra of complex nuclei and was later applied to other systems, including quantum - chaotic systems.
- It is generally assumed that if the energy - level spacing distribution of a system conforms to the RMT prediction, then its other statistical properties (such as eigenvector statistics and entanglement entropy) should also conform to the RMT prediction.
### Main Findings of the Paper
1. **Kicked Ising Spin Chain Model**:
- The authors studied the kicked Ising spin chain model with two parameter sets. For one parameter set, all properties of the system conform to the RMT prediction, while for the other parameter set, although the energy - level spacing distribution and the eigenvector statistics conform to RMT, the entanglement entropy significantly deviates from the Page curve.
2. **Effective Hamiltonian Analysis**:
- To understand the reasons for this different behavior, the authors introduced a new quantity - an analysis based on the effective Hamiltonian of the kicked system.
- Specifically, the authors analyzed the distribution of the effective spin - interaction strength and compared it with the analytical results of the circular ensemble.
- By grouping the effective interactions involving \(k\) spins, the authors found that for systems with smaller entanglement entropy, the 2 - spin interaction is more significant, and as \(k\) increases, the effective interaction weakens.
### Conclusion
The paper shows that even if the energy - level spacing distribution of a system conforms to the RMT prediction, it is not guaranteed that its entanglement entropy also conforms to the RMT prediction. This difference stems from the different behaviors of the effective spin interactions, especially the enhancement of the 2 - spin interaction and the weakening of the high - order spin interactions. This provides a new perspective for understanding the quantum - chaotic characteristics of quantum many - body systems.
### Formula Summary
- **Wigner Distribution** (COE Energy - Level Spacing Distribution):
\[
P_{\text{COE}}(s)\approx\frac{\pi}{2}s\exp\left(-\frac{\pi}{4}s^{2}\right)
\]
- **Porter - Thomas Distribution** (COE Eigenvector Distribution):
\[
P_{\text{COE}}(\eta)=\exp\left(-\frac{\eta}{2}\right)\sqrt{\frac{2}{\pi\eta}}
\]
- **von Neumann Entropy**:
\[
S =-\text{tr}(\rho_1\ln(\rho_1))
\]
where \(\rho_1=\text{tr}_2(\rho)\) is the reduced density matrix of subsystem 1.
- **Page Curve** (Average von Neumann Entropy):
\[
S_{\text{COE}}=\ln(N_1)-\frac{N_1}{2N_2}
\]
This formula is applicable for the case of \(1\ll N_1\leq N_2\).
Through these analyses, the paper reveals the complex relationship between the entanglement entropy and the RMT prediction in quantum many - body systems and proposes directions for further research.