On the Drag Coefficient Universality of a Rough Grain in Creeping Flow

Si Suo,Deheng Wei,Budi Zhao,Chongpu Zhai,Yixiang Gan

2024-11-13

Abstract:Controversy exists regarding whether grain morphology reduces or enhances the drag of a single grain in creeping flows; further complication occurs when orientation dependence for aspherical grains comes into play. To quantify influences of shape irregularity and orientation, this study numerically investigates the drag in creeping flows for fractally rough grains depicted by Spherical Harmonics. As the grain surface becomes more angular with increasing relative roughness and fractal dimension, a stronger drag reduction is observed; this observed morphology-dependent reduction indicates Stokes formula is insufficient. The rotational dependence helps to explain the paradox wherein drag enhancement is always encountered insettling-grain experiments popular in geophysics. For the drag of a given rough grain at various orientations, extracted distributions of the overall drag, and its two components, i.e., skin friction and pressure drag, universally adhere to the Weibull patterns. Moreover, we identify a universal power law between drag coefficients and a newly proposed area-related number, sufficiently taking into consideration both grain roughness by surface area and orientational dependence by projected area perpendicular to the flow direction. This law is primarily controlled by relative roughness, with less sensitivity to fractal dimension. The determined expression enables precise estimation of fluid-particle interactions in upscaling simulations.

Fluid Dynamics,Geophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is whether the drag coefficient of rough particles in creeping flow is universal and how the particle morphology affects the drag of a single particle in creeping flow. Specifically, the research focuses on the following aspects:

1. **Influence of particle morphology on drag**: Explore how the shape irregularity and directionality of particles affect their drag in creeping flow. Traditionally, most studies assume that particles are ideally spherical, but particles in nature usually have multi - scale roughness, which may lead to changes in drag.

2. **Universality of drag coefficient**: Study whether there are universal laws for the drag coefficients of rough particles with different morphologies and directions in creeping flow. In particular, researchers hope to verify through numerical simulation whether the drag coefficients of these particles follow a certain statistical distribution pattern, such as the Weibull distribution.

3. **Analysis of drag components**: Analyze how the two main components of drag - surface friction and pressure drag - change with particle morphology and direction. The study found that as the particle surface becomes more angular, the drag decreases, especially the surface friction decreases more significantly.

4. **Contradiction between experiment and simulation**: Explain why the drag enhancement phenomenon observed in the sedimentation experiment contradicts the drag reduction phenomenon observed in theory and numerical simulation. The study believes that in the sedimentation experiment, particles tend to fall in a way that the maximum projected area is perpendicular to the flow direction, resulting in a higher measured drag coefficient in the experiment.

Through these studies, the paper aims to provide a more accurate theoretical basis for the modeling of low - Reynolds - number fluid - particle interactions and provide valuable references for large - scale fluid - particle system simulations.