Abstract:Motivated by near term quantum computing hardware limitations, combinatorial optimization problems that can be addressed by current quantum algorithms and noisy hardware with little or no overhead are used to probe capabilities of quantum algorithms such as the Quantum Approximate Optimization Algorithm (QAOA). In this study, a specific class of near term quantum computing hardware defined combinatorial optimization problems, Ising models on heavy-hex graphs both with and without geometrically local cubic terms, are examined for their classical computational hardness via empirical computation time scaling quantification. Specifically the Time-to-Solution metric using the classical heuristic simulated annealing is measured for finding optimal variable assignments (ground states), as well as the time required for the optimization software Gurobi to find an optimal variable assignment. Because of the sparsity of these Ising models, the classical algorithms are able to find optimal solutions efficiently even for large instances (i.e. $100,000$ variables). The Ising models both with and without geometrically local cubic terms exhibit average-case linear-time or weakly quadratic scaling when solved exactly using Gurobi, and the Ising models with no cubic terms show evidence of exponential-time Time-to-Solution scaling when sampled using simulated annealing. These findings point to the necessity of developing and testing more complex, namely more densely connected, optimization problems in order for quantum computing to ever have a practical advantage over classical computing. Our results are another illustration that different classical algorithms can indeed have exponentially different running times, thus making the identification of the best practical classical technique important in any quantum computing vs. classical computing comparison.

Quantum combinatorial optimization beyond the variational paradigm: simple schedules for hard problems

Performant near-term quantum combinatorial optimization

Schedule Path Optimization for Adiabatic Quantum Computing and Optimization

Optimization by quantum annealing: lessons from hard satisfiability problems

Classical Combinatorial Optimization Scaling for Random Ising Models on 2D Heavy-Hex Graphs

Non-variational Quantum Combinatorial Optimisation

Solving non-native combinatorial optimization problems using hybrid quantum-classical algorithms

On the emerging potential of quantum annealing hardware for combinatorial optimization

An adaptive quantum approximate optimization algorithm for solving combinatorial problems on a quantum computer

Qubit-efficient quantum combinatorial optimization solver

Combinatorial Optimization with Quantum Computers

Unstructured Adiabatic Quantum Optimization: Optimality with Limitations

Quantum Annealing for Constrained Optimization

Quantum-Enhanced Greedy Combinatorial Optimization Solver

A benchmarking study of quantum algorithms for combinatorial optimization

Optimizing Schedules for Quantum Annealing

Squeezing and quantum approximate optimization

Multivariable Optimization: Quantum Annealing & Computation

Benchmarking Variational Quantum Algorithms for Combinatorial Optimization in Practice

Circumventing superexponential runtimes for hard instances of quantum adiabatic optimization

Necessary Adiabatic Run Times in Quantum Optimization