RoundTable: Investigating Group Decision-Making Mechanism in Multi-Agent Collaboration

Young-Min Cho,Raphael Shu,Nilaksh Das,Tamer Alkhouli,Yi-An Lai,Jason Cai,Monica Sunkara,Yi Zhang

2024-11-12

Abstract:This study investigates the efficacy of Multi-Agent Systems in eliciting cross-agent communication and enhancing collective intelligence through group decision-making in a decentralized setting. Unlike centralized mechanisms, where a fixed hierarchy governs social choice, decentralized group decision-making allows agents to engage in joint deliberation. Our research focuses on the dynamics of communication and decision-making within various social choice methods. By applying different voting rules in various environments, we find that moderate decision flexibility yields better outcomes. Additionally, exploring the linguistic features of agent-to-agent conversations reveals indicators of effective collaboration, offering insights into communication patterns that facilitate or hinder collaboration. Finally, we propose various methods for determining the optimal stopping point in multi-agent collaborations based on linguistic cues. Our findings contribute to a deeper understanding of how decentralized decision-making and group conversation shape multi-agent collaboration, with implications for the design of more effective MAS environments.

Multiagent Systems,Artificial Intelligence

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### What problems does this paper attempt to solve?

This paper aims to explore the group decision - making mechanism of multi - agent systems (MAS) in decentralized environments, especially the role in cross - agent communication and collective intelligence enhancement. Specifically, the paper mainly focuses on the following issues:

1. **Effectiveness of decentralized group decision - making**:
- Research the performance of different social choice methods (such as unanimous voting, majority voting, scored voting, etc.) in multi - agent collaboration.
- Evaluate how these methods affect the quality, efficiency, fairness, and rationality of group decision - making.

2. **Linguistic features in multi - agent collaboration**:
- Explore the dialogue patterns between agents and identify which linguistic features are signs of effective collaboration.
- Provide a new method based on linguistic cues to analyze cooperative and competitive behaviors in multi - agent interactions.

3. **Determination of the optimal stopping point**:
- Propose multiple methods to determine the best stopping point in multi - agent collaboration, avoid redundancy and stagnation, and optimize the decision - making process.
- Use linguistic features and other indicators to judge when to end the collaboration to obtain the best results.

4. **Ability to adapt to complex environments**:
- Test the performance of multi - agent systems in two environments, namely the simulated economy and the recommendation system, and verify their adaptability and effectiveness in different scenarios.

Through the research of these problems, the paper hopes to provide theoretical basis and technical support for designing more effective multi - agent systems, especially in decentralized environments, how to better realize the collaboration and decision - making between agents.

### Formula examples

Some formulas involved in the paper are as follows:

- **Individual utility function**:
\[
u_i : X \to \mathbb{R}
\]
where \(X\) is the set of all possible world states, and \(u_i\) represents each agent's preference for a certain state.

- **Proposal function**:
\[
p_i = f_p(u_i, C_i, X)
\]
where \(C_i\) contains environmental information, background, and collaboration history.

- **Voting function**:
\[
v_{ij} = f_v(u_i, C_i, S | p_i \in S \subseteq X)
\]
where \(S\) is the list of candidate proposals.

- **Social choice method**:
\[
x^* = F(p_i, v_{ij} | i, j \in I)
\]
where \(F\) is the social choice function that determines the final group decision.

Through these formulas, the paper constructs a complete framework to analyze and evaluate the group decision - making process in multi - agent systems.